On 4/18/2012 12:37 PM, [email protected] wrote:
Well, I disagree even with Ms. Rice about the actors chosen for
Interview with a Vampire but the screenplay was so bad I have no idea
if the movie was horrible because of them or not.
That being said...
Does it matter how people get to material? I read this article today -
http://io9.com/5902560/10-ways-self+hating-fans-make-genre-entertainment-worse
In it is a biggie I hear all the time - "9. Complaining that your
favorite thing is too popular now."
Once upon a time in the Highlander Convention circuit I became friends
with and still maintain a friendship with a lot of the cast. Jim
Byrnes is a great guy. He played a character that was a blues
guitarist (as he is in real life) and did some songs on the show.
I think he is a journeyman guitarist and writer at best. He has a
band that is popular locally where he lives and among Highlander
fandom they think he is a god of the guitar.
As a musician myself and music fan I think not so great but good.
But every time I see a geek that would have NEVER listened to the
blues otherwise if not for liking his character I have to go "Well,
whatever it took to get them there."
So I agree with REF. Not one word of a book was changed because of a
TV show/movie/comic or whatever. Just be glad that other people like
what you do as well now for whatever reason.
As a funny side note I cannot stand the Twilight books. I have tried
over and over. Working for DragonCon I got to know Stephenie rather
well and find her a great person but I just cannot get into her books.
At work a very undereducated and condescending of things geeky woman
loved the movies and read all the books because of them. All I could
say was "Well, at least she is reading something."
Edward deGruy
Thank you for posting that. Everything on that list is so true and sadly
it applies to most of us.
Having spent my whole adult life working in the entertainment industry,
it's a constant plague we deal with on a day to day basis. The bad thing
is that human psychology dictates that the majority of us end up
following suit in these evil trends because we as humans like to play
follow the leader. The good ones see the signs early on and put a stop
to it for themselves, but it seems some can't be saved.
10. Leading a backlash against successful creators, and rooting for
things to fail
It seems I see this much more among those who can be considered
elitists. They are the ones whom call themselves audiophiles or movie
buffs (Not sure if there is a coined phrase for book lovers or not).
I've lost quite a few friends because of this.
9. Complaining that your favorite thing is too popular now
Especially true of the music industry or Hipster subculture. I think the
common phrase is "I liked (name) before it was famous!" Hearing things
like that makes me want to take a baseball bat to their heads.
Especially if they don't like it anymore BECAUSE it's famous, which is
ironic because before it was famous, they were the ones promoting it to
get it famous...
8. Pretending to be into something way more obscure than what you
actually like.
I think we all know a Sci-Fi or music genre geek who is like this. Makes
no sense to me.
7. Claiming we're into health food when we're actually only into candy
With this mentality, I still can't figure out how Nickleback is making
money.
6. Being defensive when creators from other genres try their hand at SF
or fantasy
This hits a little close to home for me and has been a cause of my
pausing on some projects. As a musician, I've had my hand in the rock
and cinematic industries for years Recently I've started producing EDM
(Electronic Dance Music) because I've really been into it the past few
years and enjoy it immensely. There are many people out there I'm sure
would refuse to listen to my EDM simply because it's not my normal gig.
I've also wanted to publish a book I was working on, but essentially
gave up on that project because I didn't want to be limited to a single
area of interest. The same for acting. It's something I'd like to take a
stab at, but would want to be judged on my abilities, not be "that
musician trying to act".
5. Not speaking up and defending our favorite stories when people launch
unfair critiques.
God forbid. What would they think?!
4. Getting squirrelly when people want to analyze what's really going on
in these stories.
Something that really annoyed me about Lord of the Rings uberfans.
3. Looking down on some other group of fans
Yet another major issue in the entertainment industry as a whole. I'll
never understand it, yet it's been going on for as long as I can remember.
2. Not being able to appreciate cheesy, old-school stuff on its own terms.
Have to do it because it's posh.
1. Not recognizing when we're being enablers
Goes back to what I was saying about human nature, I think.
By the way, I'm terribly jealous you got to go to the Highlander
convention. Though I prefer the movies to the telly show, Highlander is
my favourite movie and Lambert is my favourite actor.
CJ*
*