On 2021-03-05 21:31, pdr0 wrote:
Mark Filipak (ffmpeg) wrote
On 2021-03-05 11:13, James Darnley wrote:
On 05/03/2021, Mark Filipak (ffmpeg) wrote:
I seek a fields-to-frames filter that does not add cosmetics. In my
pursuit,
I look for such a
filter every time I peruse the filter docs for anything. I've yet to
find
such a filter.

Do you know of a fields-to-frames filter that does not add cosmetics?

separatefields - "splits each frame into its components fields,
producing a new half height clip with twice the frame rate and twice
the frame count"

Yes, I could do (and have done) that, followed by 'shuffleframes=00',
followed by 'tinterlace' [1].
But that seems like a lengthy (slow) way to do what should be a simple
(faster) thing [2].

[1] [A+b] ==> [A][b] ==> [A][A] ==> [A+A]
[2] [A+b] ==> [A+A]


If you're curious about what I'm doing, look:
[A+a][B+c][C+d][D+d][D+d]   ...SOURCE is a (consistent) mess [3]
[A+A][a+a][B+B][c+c][C+C][d+d][D+D][d+d][D+D][d+d]
...yadif=mode=send_field
[A+A][a+a][B+B][B+B][C+C][c+c][D+D][d+d]   ...shuffleframes=0 1 2 2 4 3 6
7 -1 -1
[A+a][B+B][C+c][D+d]   ...tinterlace=mode=interleave_bottom to make TARGET
[4]

[3] Telecined (=30fps) ==> frame 1 discard (=24fps) ==> frame 3 repeat
(=30fps).
[4] The TARGET is beautiful. No cosmetic filtering needed (or possible).


[A+a][B+c][C+d][D+d][D+d]   ...SOURCE
[A][a][B][c][C][d][D][d][D][d]   ...separatefields
[A][a][B][B][C][c][D][d]   ...shuffleframes=0 1 2 2 4 3 6 7 -1 -1
[A+a][B+B][C+c][D+d]   ...weave=first_field=top to make TARGET

Hmmm... That appears to work. I'll try it.

I guess I got stuck on using tinterlace as the last step and couldn't see
that separatefields &
weave would be simpler (and faster) than yadif and without yadif's
cosmetics.

Thanks!


Yes, yadif is not the right filter for what you're doing, because of the
spatial interpolation. Yadif is a deinterlacer, and as a general rule you
don't deinterlace progressive content (that has matching field pairs), or
you'll degrade it

I think it would be helpful if I clarified. I've got 2 balls in the air. 1, go with what I outline above (specifically [B+B]), or 2, allow [c] to mate with [B] (in addition to mating with [C]) and apply yadif to just the [B+c] frame, thusly:

[A+a][B+c][C+d][D+d][D+d]   ...SOURCE
[A][a][B][c][C][d][D][d][D][d]   ...separatefields
[A][a][B][c][C][c][D][d]   ...shuffleframes=0 1 2 3 4 3 6 7 -1 -1
[A+a][B+c][C+c][D+d]   ...yadif(frame n%4==1 only),weave=first_field=top

The video is an actor making a comment. Her name fades in-out, below and to the 
right.

The more I look at the bob of that text in the [B+B] frame (otherwise the bob is not noticeable), the more I'm leaning towards some sort of cosmetics even if it introduces a very, very slight judder (i.e. c][C+c] is effectively 1+1/2 frames).

In my first tries (a couple of days ago), I applied yadif to all frames and didn't like the results. I hate fuzzy and I hate judder even more, but now I'm considering both for what is effectively +1/2 frame.

Mark Filipak (ffmpeg) wrote
[4] The TARGET is beautiful. No cosmetic filtering needed (or possible).

Cosmetic filter is wanted and possible on B+B.

B is an orphaned field, missing it's partner "b" . B+B is going to be full
of aliasing/stairstepping...

Since it's for only 1/24th second, aliasing & bob really are not noticeable (except for the aforementioned text). (BTW, the ffmpeg docs have only 3 references to the word 'alias'. All 3 are in '8.6 acrusher'. Are the devs avoiding the word 'alias' for a reason?)

... The field interpolation algorithm used to
generate the pseudo "b" makes a difference. For example, -vf nnedi=field=t
applied selectively on that B+B frame will look substantially better, almost
like a fake B+b . Or temporally filtered B+b (from A+a and C+c data), such
as with QTGMC in vapoursynth or avisynth will look better than either. If
you want demos or more info let me know

Thanks for the offer. You're very generous. I'll try hard to not burden you.

I experimented with 'nnedi' a couple of months ago and will retrieve my notes. And I do pipe to/from VapourSynth for other tasks (mostly to use InterFrame) so I'm somewhat familiar with it. I'll try both your suggestions (and I'll try to not be too stupid).

You've given me a good push. Thanks so much for the guidance!
_______________________________________________
ffmpeg-user mailing list
[email protected]
https://ffmpeg.org/mailman/listinfo/ffmpeg-user

To unsubscribe, visit link above, or email
[email protected] with subject "unsubscribe".

Reply via email to