Noel Stoutenburg wrote:
David W. Fenton wrote:
Well, a Finale file is a database file, not a computer program, like a VB file (or VBA in the case of Word). Data is not copyrightable, soI think that it would be a gray area.
In Adobe v. SSI, Adobe succeeded in persuading the court that the definitions of the glyphs in a type face met the definition of "computer program", and as such were eligible for copyright protection. If glyphs in a typeface constitute a "computer program", then by the same reasoning, the output from a Finale program would also be a "computer program".


But the difference is that the glyphs represent a non-copyrightable item, the typeface, so there is no underlying copyright in the item being represented.

A finale file, whether considered a computer program or a data file, is merely another representation of a copyrighted original, and the copyright law says that ALL derivative works and other representations (recordings, braille publication, performances) are protected by the same copyright, so the Finale file, being merely another representation in a different medium of a copyrighted original, would be covered by the original copyright.

Now the area of copyright law which currently in the US renders a separate copyright in a recorded performance might enter into consideration, but I think it would take a court case (which I certainly don't have the resources to undertake) to force a decision as to whether a Finale file, being in essence an electronic performable rendition of a copyrighted piece of music, would be able to be copyrighted in the same way that a recording can be.

But of course, nobody can do anything with a copyrighted performance without also paying for use of the copyright of the original music which is embodied in that recorded performance. And of course the performers had to pay performance royalties (or the venues the performance was recorded in) and/or recording royalties in order to produce the recording. So I wonder if claiming copyright in a Finale file would also force the payment of a royalty fee to the copyright owner for each copy of that file made. And since the copyrighted work may well never have been performed before, those mechanical reproduction royalties are completely up to the original copyright owner to set, so claiming copyright in a Finale file might result in a royalty bill of huge size.

As always, though, it's fun to speculate on these things but in the end that's all this sort of discussion is -- mere speculation. Until a court case is brought concerning copyright in Finale files as separate from the copyright in the represented musical work, nobody knows for certain what the law will be.

--
David H. Bailey
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to