On 18 Jan 2007 at 23:41, Daniel Wolf wrote:

> David W. Fenton wrote:
>
> > I think this kind of thing works better on harpsichord because
> > tuning problems are not going to be nearly as obvious, since the
> > decay ameliorates any clashes. Do you do much with organ continuo?
> 
> More important than the decay is the attack, which as a plucked string
> includes a marked inharmonic or noise component (no, the noise
> component has nothing to do with the sound of the mechanism). The
> partials in the sustained portion of a plucked string are harmonic,
> and thus tunable to just intervals by eliminating beats.  One
> advantage of the harpsichord (or another plucked string instrument) as
> a continuo instrument is that the initial noise and rapid decay of the
> harmonic portion (rapid, that is in contrast to the rest of the
> ensemble) may give the ensemble more flexibility in intonation, while
> adding a percussive character.

I find it much harder to tune my viol to harpsichord than to organ -- 
I always have to tune sharp of my natural gut feeling for the pitch 
in order to end up in tune. I've certainly learned how to adapt since 
I've done quite a lot of it, but I know that the less-experienced 
viol players in my consort have a much harder time of it. It's also 
easier to tune a gamba to the harpsichord than it is to tune a treble 
or the higher notes of the tenor.

I would note, though, that the organ we use (a portative having one 
rank of wooden stopped flutes with lots of chiff) has its own tuning 
issues, especially in the lower range, where the fundamental is very 
weak and the partials rather oddly spaced (the bottom notes of the 
short octave always sound out of tune to me when played in a scale, 
but in chords blend perfectly). And the high degree of chiff is full 
of non-harmonic noise, but is then followed by an upper partial-rich 
sustained tone.

And, of course, there's the issue of having to adjust in a 
performance as the keyboard instruments go out of tune (which they 
unfortunately do with alarming frequency, especially in contexts 
where they were moved into the performance space just hours before 
the performance). I'll often *not* tune my open strings to an out-of-
tune pitch on a keyboard instrument, and use a tunable stopped string 
when I need to play a unison with an out-of-string note. I would 
assume this is pretty much something that decent continouo players do 
as a matter of course, given that I'm barely even what one would call 
competent. It's much more complicated in a viol consort with organ 
parts (continuo or written-out) -- in that case you need a whole 
consort of players capable of adjusting, and I've never had the 
pleasure of playing in a consort at that level. Maybe it does work, 
but we seem to have better luck playing in tune with the organ and 
with each other when working in ET than we did for the several months 
we tried 6th-comma mean tone.

-- 
David W. Fenton                    http://dfenton.com
David Fenton Associates       http://dfenton.com/DFA/

_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to