One of the fringe benefits of having a unified Fink/DarwinPorts distfile
fetching system is a comparison of MD5's for files listed in both projects.
The fetching script complains when there is a mismatch in what the 
desired MD5 of the distfile is.  I've mentioned this on IRC from time
to time, but no one seemed particularly concerned since usually this
is a project maintainer doing something evil and either the Fink .info
file or the DarwinPorts Portfile needs to be updated.
However, I was talking with olegb on irc today, and we found Eterm
had a mismatched MD5.  Upon further investigation, Fink uses sourceforge
as the sole source of the Eterm sources, but DP uses eterm.org, and then
falls back to using sourceforge.  Eterm.org is distributing a different
tarball from what sourceforge distributes.  This is a bad thing, and
eterm.org has been notified of the discrepancy.
Anyway, that's just an example of why checking up on these things is
a good thing.

Here is the list of current mismatched md5's:
ERROR: X11R6.8.1-src3.tar.gz appeared more than once with different md5's
ERROR: icecast-1.3.12.tar.gz appeared more than once with different md5's
ERROR: mp3splt-2.0-src.tar.gz appeared more than once with different md5's
ERROR: X11R6.8.1-src1.tar.gz appeared more than once with different md5's
ERROR: fnlib-0.5.tar.gz appeared more than once with different md5's
ERROR: X11R6.8.1-src6.tar.gz appeared more than once with different md5's
ERROR: X11R6.8.1-src7.tar.gz appeared more than once with different md5's
ERROR: X11R6.8.1-src5.tar.gz appeared more than once with different md5's
ERROR: X11R6.8.1-src4.tar.gz appeared more than once with different md5's
ERROR: X11R6.8.1-src2.tar.gz appeared more than once with different md5's
ERROR: Eterm-0.9.2.tar.gz appeared more than once with different md5's
ERROR: p4 appeared more than once with different md5's

icecast and p4 (and possibly fnlib) have had mismatched md5's since
this distfile script first started running (over a year ago?).

I'm not sure who needs to update what, so I'm sending this to both
the darwinports and fink mailing lists.  Ideally, the respective 
maintainers will check up to make sure they are doing the right thing,
whatever that may be.

FYI, this information is available to anyone who wants it, although not
in a nice form.  The output of the distfiles mirroring script gets sent
to [EMAIL PROTECTED]  Anyone can subscribe, and the archives
are available.

Rob


-------------------------------------------------------
SF email is sponsored by - The IT Product Guide
Read honest & candid reviews on hundreds of IT Products from real users.
Discover which products truly live up to the hype. Start reading now. 
http://productguide.itmanagersjournal.com/
_______________________________________________
Fink-devel mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/fink-devel

Reply via email to