Here are my comments regarding the proposed FOP logo designs.
Number correspond to logos at http://vote.sparklit.com/web_poll.spark/714566_ :


1. ready for a change
2. Is attractive but does not say much to me about FOP
3. Too symbolic of the ANT project
4. nice - Clean like the use of transparency
5. same as 4, like the blue on 5 better
6. not interested in this one
7. nice - but dislike the Font used for FOP.
8. not interested in this one- not elegant enough
9. not interested in this one - not elegant enough
10. nice - but concerned about the text behind that would get lost at a reduced logo size. I think the use of lowercase actually works in this logo since the spelled out version is also lower case
11. not interested in this one
12. similar to 11
13. Like this one but would like to see a different font used for the "f" and "p". seems like the F,O, and P should be lowercase to match the bigger letters that are lowercase.
14. not interested in this one - To much flair
15. not interested in this one
16. not interested in this one
17. nice - but i think it looks to much like 3 different elements rather then one logo
18. like this one - but concerned again about the type in the background getting lost at a smaller logo size. Also it looks more like a layout rather then a logo.
19. not interested in this one
20. nice - i like the way this one shows a process of being empty then going through the apache quill, then becoming transformed into a filled object.
21. nice - like the way it shows the "fo". could be made a little more compact. not sure if it would look as nice if it was converted to one color.
22. similar comments as 21
23. not interested in this one - does not say much to me about FOP
24. not interested in this one - does not say much to me about FOP
25. not interested in this one - imagery is not clear enough on this one
26 -29. not interested in this one - looks like something you might see at a tattoo parlor or on the side of a mailbox :)


top choices:
4, 7, 10, 13, 18, 20, 21

top 4+ would be:
7 (different font with the ink and quill placed artfully in front of the 'O'
10 (i'd like to see the background tags move down three lines and end the tags where they do currently.
13 (with a little refinement on the font for the 'f' and 'p'
20


18 (i think i would have to throw out 18 becuase it looks more like a layout then a logo - unless of course it were reworked)

-Scott
--

Scott Hofmann | [EMAIL PROTECTED]

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Reply via email to