Jon Hamilton wrote:

> No.  ipfw deals with /etc/services only at startup time (any other behavior on
> its part would be ridiculous).

        That's not entirely true, there are other situations (like adding a 
rule,
etc.) but your point is well taken. And no, I can't provide specific
examples, my point is really much simpler than that. 
 
> I think you're  overestimating the cost by a considerable amount.  I'm
> not saying that the cost is zero, but I am saying that it's close enough
> that the value of having the information *right there* outweighs the cost.

        Anyone interested in the information will stay interested long enough to
look it up in a man page. Even if the cost to the system is very very
small, I think that adding it to the file is silly when it could just as
easily be added to a man page. 

        Of course, there are other benefits to having it in a man page too. The
primary one being that changes/updates to the comments don't require a
change to the file, and would be picked up automatically during a make
world. 

        Now you'll have to excuse me while I go sharpen my lance...

Doug


To Unsubscribe: send mail to majord...@freebsd.org
with "unsubscribe freebsd-hackers" in the body of the message

Reply via email to