ok, bonne info : cela eclairerait nos scenarios où le lacp cuivre ne 
marchait pas.

    les SFP que nous utilisions n'etaient pas des brocade et necessitaient 
d'enlever l'auto-neg
    en cuivre (speed 1000)

    d'où on se retrouvait avec un scenario inconsistant avec lacp.

-- 
    Jean-Daniel Pauget                         http://rezopole.net/
    Rezopole/LyonIX                            +33 (0)4 27 46 00 50


On Tue, Sep 04, 2018 at 02:11:51PM +0200, Mathieu Poussin wrote:
> Désolé j'en mélange mes langues :)
> 
> J'ai pu trouver la solution... Si on force speed a 1G ça pose des soucis... 
> Le message est pas très explicite.
> https://gtacknowledge.extremenetworks.com/articles/Q_A/Setting-1GB-SFP-on-VDX-to-speed-1000-brings-link-down
> 
> Je laisse ça la si ca peut aider dans le future.
> 
> Merci :)
> 
> 
>  ---- On Tue, 04 Sep 2018 13:58:34 +0200 Mathieu Poussin <m...@mpouss.in> 
> wrote ---- 
>  > Ok I just found in the logs :  
>  >  
>  > Incompatible SFP transceiver for interface TenGigabitEthernet 0/35 is 
> detected 
>  >  
>  > Which is weird those are supposed to be compatible with ? 1GE-XBR-000190 
>  >  
>  > Maybe a firmware update could fix this ? (hard to say without support) Or 
> this is expected to not be compatible ? 
>  >  
>  > Thanks 
>  >  
>  >  
>  >  ---- On Tue, 04 Sep 2018 13:44:29 +0200 Mathieu Poussin <m...@mpouss.in> 
> wrote ----  
>  >  > Hello.  
>  >  >   
>  >  > Je suis en train de configurer un Brocade VDX (gray market donc pas de 
> support malheureusement).  
>  >  >   
>  >  > Impossible de monter un LACP, en faite c'est assez bizarre, le 
> Port-Channel monte bien mais impossible de no shut les membres (Qui sont des 
> ports 10g mais avec des sfp copper 1g), exemple :  
>  >  >   
>  >  > bcn-sws-3-1# show port-channel 1  
>  >  >  LACP Aggregator: Po 1  
>  >  >  Aggregator type: Standard  
>  >  >   Admin Key: 0001 - Oper Key 0001  
>  >  >   Partner System ID - 0x0000,00-00-00-00-00-00  
>  >  >   Partner Oper Key 0000  
>  >  >  Member ports:  
>  >  >    Link: Te 0/35 (0x18118184) sync: 0  
>  >  >    Link: Te 0/40 (0x18140189) sync: 0  
>  >  >    Link: Te 0/55 (0x181B8284) sync: 0  
>  >  >    Link: Te 0/60 (0x181E0289) sync: 0  
>  >  >   
>  >  > bcn-sws-3-1# sh run int po 1  
>  >  > interface Port-channel 1  
>  >  >  speed 1000  
>  >  >  description Uplink to BCN-SWC-3-1  
>  >  >  switchport  
>  >  >  switchport mode trunk  
>  >  >  switchport trunk allowed vlan add 110-112  
>  >  >  switchport trunk tag native-vlan  
>  >  >  no shutdown  
>  >  > !  
>  >  >   
>  >  > bcn-sws-3-1(config)# int te 0/35  
>  >  > bcn-sws-3-1(conf-if-te-0/35)# no shut  
>  >  > bcn-sws-3-1(conf-if-te-0/35)# end  
>  >  > bcn-sws-3-1# sh run int te 0/35  
>  >  > interface TenGigabitEthernet 0/35  
>  >  >  speed 1000  
>  >  >  description Uplink  
>  >  >  channel-group 1 mode active type standard  
>  >  >  lacp timeout long  
>  >  >  shutdown # << wtf?  
>  >  > !  
>  >  >   
>  >  >   
>  >  > bcn-sws-3-1# sh int te 0/35  
>  >  > TenGigabitEthernet 0/35 is admin down, line protocol is down (admin 
> down)  
>  >  > Hardware is Ethernet, address is 0005.334b.f97e  
>  >  >     Current address is 0005.334b.f97e  
>  >  > Pluggable media not present  
>  >  > Description: Uplink  
>  >  > Interface index (ifindex) is 403800452  
>  >  > MTU 2500 bytes  
>  >  > LineSpeed Actual     : Nil  
>  >  > LineSpeed Configured : 1000 Mbit, Duplex: Full  
>  >  > Priority Tag disable  
>  >  > IPv6 RA Guard disable  
>  >  > Last clearing of show interface counters: 03:39:48  
>  >  > Queueing strategy: fifo  
>  >  > Receive Statistics:  
>  >  >     0 packets, 0 bytes  
>  >  >     Unicasts: 0, Multicasts: 0, Broadcasts: 0  
>  >  >     64-byte pkts: 0, Over 64-byte pkts: 0, Over 127-byte pkts: 0  
>  >  >     Over 255-byte pkts: 0, Over 511-byte pkts: 0, Over 1023-byte pkts: 
> 0  
>  >  >     Over 1518-byte pkts(Jumbo): 0  
>  >  >     Runts: 0, Jabbers: 0, CRC: 0, Overruns: 0  
>  >  >     Errors: 0, Discards: 0  
>  >  > Transmit Statistics:  
>  >  >     1960 packets, 289098 bytes  
>  >  >     Unicasts: 8, Multicasts: 1302, Broadcasts: 650  
>  >  >     Underruns: 0  
>  >  >     Errors: 0, Discards: 0  
>  >  > Rate info (interval 299 seconds):  
>  >  >     Input 0.000000 Mbits/sec, 0 packets/sec, 0.00% of line-rate  
>  >  >     Output 0.000000 Mbits/sec, 0 packets/sec, 0.00% of line-rate  
>  >  > Time since last interface status change: 00:44:44  
>  >  >   
>  >  >   
>  >  > Le "Pluggable media not present" me porte a confusions vu que j'ai 
> d'autre ports 10g qui sont up, fonctionnent bien mais qui retournent aussi 
> ça, exemple:  
>  >  >   
>  >  > bcn-sws-3-1# sh int te 0/1  
>  >  > TenGigabitEthernet 0/1 is up, line protocol is up (connected)  
>  >  > Hardware is Ethernet, address is 0005.334b.f95c  
>  >  >     Current address is 0005.334b.f95c  
>  >  > Pluggable media not present  
>  >  > Description: STORAGE  
>  >  > Interface index (ifindex) is 402685952  
>  >  > MTU 2500 bytes  
>  >  > LineSpeed Actual     : 10000 Mbit  
>  >  > LineSpeed Configured : Auto, Duplex: Full  
>  >  > Priority Tag disable  
>  >  > IPv6 RA Guard disable  
>  >  > Last clearing of show interface counters: 03:42:41  
>  >  > Queueing strategy: fifo  
>  >  > Receive Statistics:  
>  >  >     145608 packets, 29709612 bytes  
>  >  >     Unicasts: 144478, Multicasts: 940, Broadcasts: 190  
>  >  >     64-byte pkts: 112543, Over 64-byte pkts: 15686, Over 127-byte pkts: 
> 2810  
>  >  >     Over 255-byte pkts: 730, Over 511-byte pkts: 613, Over 1023-byte 
> pkts: 13226  
>  >  >     Over 1518-byte pkts(Jumbo): 0  
>  >  >     Runts: 0, Jabbers: 0, CRC: 0, Overruns: 0  
>  >  >     Errors: 0, Discards: 0  
>  >  > Transmit Statistics:  
>  >  >     1176133 packets, 1658862747 bytes  
>  >  >     Unicasts: 1174922, Multicasts: 952, Broadcasts: 259  
>  >  >     Underruns: 0  
>  >  >     Errors: 0, Discards: 0  
>  >  > Rate info (interval 299 seconds):  
>  >  >     Input 0.000000 Mbits/sec, 0 packets/sec, 0.00% of line-rate  
>  >  >     Output 0.000708 Mbits/sec, 0 packets/sec, 0.00% of line-rate  
>  >  > Time since last interface status change: 01:19:15  
>  >  >   
>  >  > La version (Pas de support donc pas de MAJ malheureusement...):   
>  >  >   
>  >  > bcn-sws-3-1# show ver  
>  >  >   
>  >  > Network Operating System Software  
>  >  > Network Operating System Version: 4.1.1  
>  >  > Copyright (c) 1995-2014 Brocade Communications Systems, Inc.  
>  >  > Firmware name:      4.1.1  
>  >  > Build Time:         19:48:22 Mar 19, 2014  
>  >  > Install Time:       12:34:44 Mar 23, 2015  
>  >  > Kernel:             2.6.34.6  
>  >  >   
>  >  > BootProm:           2.2.0  
>  >  > Control Processor:  e500v2 with 2048 MB of memory  
>  >  >   
>  >  > Appl     Primary/Secondary Versions  
>  >  > ------------------------------------------  
>  >  > NOS      4.1.1  
>  >  >          4.1.1  
>  >  >   
>  >  > Une idée?  
>  >  > Pas d'accès aux forums Brocade non plus sans support alors que la 
> réponse y est surement...  
>  >  >   
>  >  > Merci  
>  >  >   
>  >  >   
>  >  >   
>  >  > ---------------------------  
>  >  > Liste de diffusion du FRnOG  
>  >  > http://www.frnog.org/  
>  >  >  
>  >  
>  > 
> 
> 
> 
> ---------------------------
> Liste de diffusion du FRnOG
> http://www.frnog.org/


---------------------------
Liste de diffusion du FRnOG
http://www.frnog.org/

Répondre à