At 16:40 02/06/2003 -0700, you wrote:
<<<<
Hello Arthur,
Your remark about mind being a process that goes on in the brain echoed
back at me in a meditative moment yesterday. You were wondering, Where is
the mind?, and if indeed we have one. I really enjoy these kinds of
questions, and ask that you consider the following:
Mind is quite apart from brain because you are free to change your mind
moment to moment. You can do so because, unlike brain and body, it is
unfettered by physical laws.
>>>>
How do you know you are free to change your mind from moment to moment?
Brain studies show very clearly that electrical potential builds up in
the relevant brain cells *before* you are conscious of taking a decision
(and apparently exercising your freewill). This was a counter-intuitive
discovery by Libet some 15 years ago of explosive significance to
philosophy and has been more thoroughly investigated -- and confirmed --
than almost anything else in neuroscience
If the mind is unfettered by physical laws and outside their ambit, then
how come you can think or say anything at all about it? Everything you
think or say is governed by the neurons in your brain and these, in turn,
are governed by exactly the same physical laws that govern every other
activity.
If one persists in thinking of the mind as some sort of free-floating
entity then you can have an infinity of different hypotheses about it and
every single one of them can be thought to be true (if anybody believes
you) simply because it can't be tested.
Keith Hudson
Keith Hudson, 6 Upper Camden Place, Bath, England
- [Futurework] RE: But where's the mind? Cordell . Arthur
- [Futurework] RE: But where's the mind? Keith Hudson
- Re: [Futurework] RE: But where's the mind? Stephen Straker
- [Futurework] No to totalitarianism Keith Hudson
- Re: [Futurework] No to totalitarian... Stephen Straker
- Re: [Futurework] RE: But where's the mi... Brad McCormick, Ed.D.
- Re: [Futurework] RE: But where's the mind? Darryl and Natalia
- Re: [Futurework] RE: But where's the mind? Keith Hudson
- Re: [Futurework] RE: But where's the mi... Selma Singer
- [Futurework] Speaking of Cesar Pell... Brad McCormick, Ed.D.
- Re: [Futurework] RE: But where's th... Brad McCormick, Ed.D.
- [Futurework] Short-circuiting ... Keith Hudson
- [Futurework] Re: Short-cir... Brad McCormick, Ed.D.
- Re: [Futurework] Re: S... Stephen Straker
- Re: [Futurework] Re: S... Brad McCormick, Ed.D.
- Re: [Futurework] RE: But where's the mi... Darryl and Natalia
- Re: [Futurework] RE: But where's th... Keith Hudson
- Re: [Futurework] RE: But where... Ray Evans Harrell