------- Additional Comments From adah at netstd dot com  2005-08-11 03:51 
-------
Hi Gaby,

I have read Sutter's Modest Proposal on fixing ADL that you referred to me.  If 
you had told me earlier about this instead of bluntly telling me this was not a 
GCC bug, I would have much more quickly given up the request to `fix' this 
behaviour.  (Hey, PLEASE do not argue with me on this: it is just an after 
comment on facts.)

Since the future is undecided on how to make the program pass (I believe it 
*is* the consensus of C++ gurus that the OP's program should compile, though it 
is undefined and nonportable under the current C++ Standard), it is premature 
to take measures to `correct' the current behaviour.  However, the error 
message *is* user unfriendly.  I suppose no one objects to this.  So my request 
is still that the error message should be improved.

Yongwei


-- 


http://gcc.gnu.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=15910

Reply via email to