I'm fine with the idea of alpha releases. I think they are important. I'm a bit confused on where this is going.
what are your criteria for declaring the 0.22 branch stable? Is compatibility with 1.0 and security a goal for this release line? --- E14 - typing on glass On Dec 2, 2011, at 1:15 AM, Konstantin Shvachko <[email protected]> wrote: > This is a well tested state of the branch, which imo worth releasing. > Adding changes at this point will invalidate the testing. > 0.23 has "substantial regressions from the stable line" as well, and > is not stable. > 1.0 does not have important features including some in MR that 0.22 has. > What is a regression! > > 0.22 is progress in at least one area, which is HDFS. > People can actually start appending data to files, use links, and > build features (e.g. HA) based on BackupNode. > HBase clusters should not be segregated anymore as HBase-only ones, > but will allow general load as well. > > Speaking of confusing. What isn't in Hadoop this days. Say, when you > transition from Hadoop 1.0 to 0.22 or 0.23 you call it upgrade. > > Seriously. This project needs to move forward beyond the 0.20 line. I > tested 0.22 in the last three months and found it working with HBase, > Hive, Pig, Cascading, Zookeeper, Oozie. What else do you need to > release? It is not perfect? Agreed. Have anybody seen a perfect piece > of software? I haven't. > > Eric, thank you for raising the question. It is important to > understand the pros and cons of different versions. > You should try the candidate, who knows it might just work for you. > > --Konstantin > > On Thu, Dec 1, 2011 at 10:26 PM, Eric Baldeschwieler > <[email protected]> wrote: >> So this release contains substantial regressions from the stable line and >> contains a subset of features in 0.23. >> >> Wouldn't it be prudent to wait until the branch is compelling when compared >> to one of the other release lines before releasing? Otherwise this just >> seems confusing. >> >> --- >> E14 - typing on glass >> >> On Dec 1, 2011, at 6:10 PM, Konstantin Boudnik <[email protected]> wrote: >> >>> +1 >>> >>> Checksum are correct, license is in place >>> Single node cluster (Ubuntu 11.04) installation and a mapreduce job worked >>> without any issues. >>> >>> Cos >>> >>> On Tue, Nov 29, 2011 at 02:47AM, Konstantin Shvachko wrote: >>>> I created a release candidate for hadoop-0.22.0 available for review at: >>>> http://people.apache.org/~shv/hadoop-0.22.0-rc0/ >>>> >>>> The candidate incorporates more than 700 fixed jiras counting from the >>>> release of 0.21.0. >>>> The branch was cut on November 17 last year. During this year the >>>> branch was tested by different groups in the Hadoop community. >>>> Recently it has been extensively tested on a mid-size cluster. >>>> It contains important improvements, optimizations and bug fixes for >>>> HDFS and MapReduce compared to 0.21.0. Some features introduced in the >>>> latest offspring releases of hadoop-security are not yet ported to >>>> this branch, which is mostly related to security and MapReduce >>>> improvements. Compared to 0.23.0 this release will not contain >>>> Federation or Yarn. >>>> The hadoop-0.22.0 release build is fully automated thanks to the >>>> BigTop team. rc0 artifacts are available and reproducible on Hadoop >>>> Jenkins. The validity of rc0 has been also verified with BigTop. >>>> I think this could be a usable release and an important step forward >>>> in the Hadoop roadmap. >>>> >>>> Many people contributed to hadoop-0.22. Thank you everybody who >>>> developed code, built, tested, found and fixed bugs or supported this >>>> effort by any other means. >>>> >>>> Please try it out and vote. >>>> >>>> Thanks, >>>> --Konstantin
