Konstantin, On Dec 3, 2011, at 4:43 PM, Konstantin Shvachko wrote: > > On Fri, Dec 2, 2011 at 9:39 PM, Arun Murthy <[email protected]> wrote: >> On Dec 2, 2011, at 1:16 AM, Konstantin Shvachko <[email protected]> wrote: >> >>> 0.23 has "substantial regressions from the stable line" as well, and >>> is not stable. >> >> Do you have a list Konstantin? We'll shoot to fix them for 0.23.1... >> > > This was not intended to criticize 0.23 release. > I am merely referring to its alpha status. > IMO 0.23 is a good and timely release.
No offense taken, we've been very clear about 'production-worthiness' of hadoop-0.23.0 at this point in time. For example, here is the warning for end-users on the releases page: http://hadoop.apache.org/common/releases.html#11+Nov%2C+2011%3A+release+0.23.0+available OTOH, if you are aware of any 'feature regressions' please bring it to our collective attention and we'll try to get them fixed for 0.23.1. One feature regression I knew of i.e. disk-fail-in-place for the NodeManager is already fixed for 0.23.1 (MAPREDUCE-3121). If you have others, please let me know. Also, we've agreed, on this list, that hadoop-0.23.1 (sometime in mid-to-late December) should be marked as 'alpha' quality as we continue to make progress stabilizing branch-0.23. Given, the 'feature' regressions in MR (security, operability etc. - http://s.apache.org/critical-0.22.0), I propose we mark hadoop-0.22.0 as 'alpha' quality too with necessary statutory warnings to end users to alert them to the differences in terms of missing features. Else, we could land up confusing users - this has come up before on this list: http://s.apache.org/Go9. Seems reasonable? On a related note - it would help if you could share your thoughts on the roadmap for releases off branch-0.22. Some questions come to mind, these would help the community (and, of course, end-users) evaluate current & future releases of the branch: # Do you plan to fix security in branch-0.22? # Do you plan to _test_ security end-to-end for the whole ecosystem? # Do you plan to fix some of the critical operability features such as disk-fail-in-place, MR tasklogs' handling etc.? # Could you share any details on the performance work/benchmarks you've done for 0.22? How does it compare to hadoop-0.20.2xx for e.g.? Various folks, at different points, have noticed performance regressions in branch-0.22 - have you checked? # Do you have timelines in mind for the above? thanks, Arun
