On Wed, 2003-12-03 at 09:29, Bruce Snyder wrote: > This one time, at band camp, Berin Lautenbach said: > > BL>> 2) Identify the PPMC who gets to name this project - and hold them > BL>> accountable for their decision. > BL> > BL>+1. I think the Incubator PMC is in a kind of unique position. We are > BL>trying to ensure that new projects/new committers in new projects are > BL>working in "The Apache Way". So for me, the Incubator PMC shouldn't > BL>actually be voting to make the decision for the incubating project. It > BL>should simply be checking that the decision has been made appropriately. > BL> If anyone in the PMC vetoes a PPMC decision it should be on the basis > BL>that the decision does not meet the ASF requirements, not on the basis > BL>that we do/don't like a name (for example). > BL> > BL>Anything else takes the decision away from the project in inubation, and > BL>I'm not sure I see how that is fostering the Apache way. > > IMO, Berin's comments are exactly what I was thinking.
Do note that there were votes from the members, not neccessarily (only) from the Incubator PMC. Sander --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
