Hi Kathleen,

 

I wish you well with your work and am interested in helping. But if I may, I’d 
like to reply to two points in your email. The first is with regard to 
“ambition.” I think it’s fair to say that both of these efforts are on the 
audacious end of the ambition scale. Our view, however---which I think is more 
reflective of the broad, global scholcomm community---is that we shouldn’t 
predefine the end goal as being “full open access” because (a) not everyone 
agrees with this approach (many prefer some other state, like “more open”), and 
(b) open means many different things to many different people in the open 
space---open has been adopted and coopted in a wide variety of ways. So, saying 
in advance that there is only one true way means we may end up with much lower 
levels of open if we can’t get everything we want.

 

Second, I mention your “least common denominator” argument in the Common Ground 
paper. It’s a reasonable point for sure, and one that we’ve heard for years in 
OSI. Here’s an excerpt from pages 12-14 that tries to speak to this concern 
(the argument continues beyond page 14---this is just the intro):

… the central premise of this paper is that by building on the common ground we 
have in this community we have a better chance of developing the right 
solutions for the future of open research in the right order and for the right 
reasons, and that these solutions will have a better chance of being adopted 
and sustained and will allow the full potential of open to flourish. From this 
common ground, and with common global action we can not only realize the full 
potential of open but also solve all the connected issues in this space, from 
affordability to predatory publishing to academia’s publish or perish culture. 

A leap of faith?

Does it require a leap of faith to agree with this premise? Yes, most 
definitely. There are many brilliant and passionate experts in this community 
who believe common ground is a mirage—that only limited or unilateral actions 
will lead to global open reforms in the near future; or that global action has 
no chance of happening so it’s better to take what we can get; or that global 
action will only achieve “watered down” open that doesn’t immediately satisfy 
our most ambitious plans. Jon Tennant summarizes other perspectives on this 
leap of faith (Tennant 2020):

First, [there is such a diversity of principles, practices and outputs involved 
that] a single, unified, comprehensive and widely-accepted consensus definition 
[of open scholarship] is probably not sufficient (or even desirable), unless 
such a definition readily embraces this diversity (e.g., as the Open 
Scholarship Initiative seems to do). Second, there remains a need to rigorously 
define and enforce the philosophy, values, and principles of Open Scholarship, 
and explore how these underpin the practices, and to have consensus reached on 
this within the scholarly community. 

This would address the lack of common understanding, which has impeded the 
widespread adoption of the strategic direction and goals behind Open 
Scholarship, prevented it from becoming a true social ‘movement’, and separated 
researchers into disintegrated groups with differing, and often contested, 
definitions and levels of adoption of openness (Tennant, Beamer, et al. 2019). 
Rebecca Willen has also identified that there might be two, perhaps three, 
different sub-movements that intersect in different ways, involving ‘open 
science’, ‘replicable science’, and ‘justice-oriented science’…. Alternatively, 
it could be the case that now, open research is diffused in such a wide variety 
of ways that there cannot plausibly be a single, cohesive community and set of 
practices that define it…. Instead, Open Scholarship, Open Research, and Open 
Science might best be thought of as overlapping/intersecting ‘boundary objects’ 
(Moore 2017) that represent this inherent diversity.

Broadly speaking, then, the difference in approach between the leapers and the 
non-leapers is that we can be inclusive or exclusive with our efforts—inclusive 
if we want to reach a broad, global, sustainable agreement; or exclusive if we 
believe that narrow, focused efforts are more practical, desirable and/or 
achievable. In the international scholarly communication community today, we 
see a large number of exclusive arrangements—from bilateral agreements between 
universities and publishers; to government mandates for domestically-funded 
research; to coordination between similarly focused advocacy groups or 
infrastructure groups (like those working to improve institutional repositories 
or editorial standards). These efforts are in addition to a vast multitude of 
unilateral reform efforts, from institutions creating their own one-off open 
access policies to publishers launching new open products and services to a new 
business ideas emerging featuring new approaches to peer review management 
(like F1000), pre-print standardization (using a framework created by the 
Center for Open Science), the brilliant SciElo network in South America (whose 
origins actually predate the open movement but which is constantly updating 
itself to stay robust and cutting edge), and more. This constellation of 
passion and energy in this community to improve the future of open is truly 
something to behold.

So why leap? Because this community’s effort to reform open research has for 
decades now been working backward from these exclusive, unilateral and/or 
specific solutions, trying to defend them, rationalize them, and/or knit them 
together. By design or circumstance, however, these solutions are often rigid 
and inflexible, meaning that integrating them—most often as an 
afterthought—into a tapestry of policies and solutions that work for broader 
audiences becomes effectively impossible. There has never been an inclusive, 
global effort to bring everyone together first—broadly, at scale and at a high, 
policy-making level—to identify common ground needs and interests, then 
collectively brainstorm options, and only then design specific policies and 
solutions that work within this globally operational and sustainable 
framework.[1] 

Our failure to work systematically like this as a community on the global 
issues and challenges of scholarly communication has led to a unique twist on 
the tragedy of the commons, where it isn't our inaction on common challenges 
that has led to problems, but the fact that we continue to act on these 
challenges in our own interests, or from our own limited perspectives, or with 
the sense that this is the best we’ll be able to do. Of course, practically 
speaking, taking a broad global approach to scholarly communication may not 
even be practical or prudent if large stakeholders—think the EU or the 
University of California system—are of the mindset that they have a legal and 
fiduciary obligation to do what’s best for their constituencies and not worry 
about the rest. But in this case, “the rest” can end up meaning the majority of 
the scholarly communication world that doesn’t have the power to craft such 
sweeping publishing agreements. So far in this debate, what happens in Vegas 
isn’t staying in Vegas but causing ripple effects throughout the scholarly 
communication environment. And again this isn’t so much of an issue if we’re 
certain these ripple effects will have positive impacts. We don’t know this, 
though. We do know that impacts are rippling everywhere. Where the system finds 
a new equilibrium is anyone’s guess as well as whether this new equilibrium is 
better than before (for everyone) or worse.

This exclusivity and the resulting lack of inclusivity of ideas about the 
future of open has been perhaps the defining deficiency of most of the 
collaborative actions that have happened in our community to-date. Most of the 
discussions about open reforms have just involved libraries, publishers, a few 
funders, and a few active scholars, and have revolved around what open means 
and what policies we’ll need to get there from here.  But there are many other 
facets to this conversation, and many other stakeholders affect and are 
affected by changes in the ecosystem; the scholarly communication ecosystem 
differs in significant ways across the globe and between researchers, 
institutions and fields of study; and there are many questions that exclusive 
action can’t address. Issues aside there are also broader ecosystem-level 
questions that need answering, such as what is our collective goal in pursuing 
open policies? What are we going to do with this information we’re collecting 
(and why)? Who is asking and answering these questions and are we sure the 
questions and answers we’re providing (via our narrow group of debate 
participants) actually represent the best interest of global research and 
global researchers?

To be clear the scholarly communication community’s limited and exclusive 
groups have collaborated over the years with vigor and success. There has been 
broad cooperation and collaboration between aligned interest groups, advocacy 
groups, groups with similar regional interests, groups with similar ideological 
bents and so on. This kind of cooperation and collaboration has helped push 
forward progress on open and raise the profile of the need for open. Also, as 
Şentürk (2001) noted, there is power in the fact that different parts of the 
scholarly communication community understand and adopt their own understanding 
of openness in different ways depending on their norms and processes. Neither 
of these dynamics—limited engagements or a variety of adoption paths—should 
change.

What is missing is that it’s unlikely only limited engagement and/or varied 
adoption paths will ever by themselves result in broad and comprehensive 
solutions to scholarly communication’s systemic issues. And these dynamics 
certainly won’t result in off-the-shelf global, universally-acceptable 
solutions or solutions that work for groups whose needs differ from those of 
the negotiating groups. It’s hard to envision a system more global and more 
integrated than research; global approaches are needed.

Best regards,

Glenn

 

Glenn Hampson
Executive Director
Science Communication Institute (SCI)
Program Director
Open Scholarship Initiative (OSI)



 

 

From: Kathleen Shearer <[email protected]> 
Sent: Monday, April 20, 2020 11:26 AM
To: Richard Poynder <[email protected]>
Cc: Glenn Hampson <[email protected]>; [email protected]; 
Global Open Access List (Successor of AmSci) <[email protected]>
Subject: Re: [SCHOLCOMM] Fostering Bibliodiversity in Scholarly Communications: 
A Call for Action

 

Hi Richard,

 

I didn’t notice your question about cOAlition S overlap with COAR. There is 
probably some small overlap in institutional membership, but most of the COAR 
members are not funders and cOAlition S members generally are funders. That 
said, COAR and cOAlition S are working together in the area of repositories. 

 

In terms of collaboration, I have been aware of Glen’s initiative, but my 
co-authors and I (as well as many others) have a more ambitious goal. That is, 
to move towards full, open access and at the same time support and nurture 
bibliodiversity. 

 

In terms of collaboration, I think the “big tent” strategy can too easily 
result in lowest common denominator, watered-down objectives as well as erase 
any local, diverse, unique perspectives. A much more effective approach would 
be (and I reiterate) to develop regional or national strategies between 
funders, universities, libraries and researchers + international engagement 
across each community (like Plan S for funders or COAR for repositories).

 

And, in response to Heather, of course the translation technologies are not 
perfect, but this is about having “good enough” tools to support global 
communications, while also ensuring local populations have access to their 
local scientific and scholarly output.

 

Best, Kathleen

 

 

Kathleen Shearer

Executive Director

Confederation of Open Access Repositories (COAR)

www.coar-repositories.org <http://www.coar-repositories.org> 

 

 





On Apr 20, 2020, at 12:40 PM, Richard Poynder <[email protected] 
<mailto:[email protected]> > wrote:

 

Thanks for this Glenn, the fact that these two initiatives have emerged within 
days of each other without any apparent co-ordination (presumably because 
neither knew about the other one?) makes me wonder whether a new spirit of 
collaboration and cohesiveness is indeed emerging.  

 

I also wonder about the compatibility of the two groups. The Call for Action 
document appears to be a scholar-led initiative expressing concern about the 
role that what are referred to as the oligopolists are playing in the scholarly 
publishing space. For instance, it states, “For decades, commercial companies 
in the academic publishing sector have been carrying out portfolio building 
strategies based on mergers and acquisitions of large companies as well as 
buying up small publishers or journals. The result of this has been a 
concentration of players in the sector, which today is dominated by a small 
number of companies who own thousands of journals and dozens of presses.”

 

OSI appears to have been receiving funding from precisely these kind of 
companies, including legacy publishers and other for-profit organisations 
(http://osiglobal.org/sponsors/). In fact, in 2019 it seems to have received 
funding only from for-profit organisations. Or am I misreading? I realise the 
sums concerned are small, but it does make me wonder whether OSI can really do 
meaningful business with the authors of the Call to Action. 

 

I realise you were anticipating “a few boo birds” on mailing lists on the 
announcement of Plan A 
(https://groups.google.com/forum/#!msg/osi2016-25/J9dJdeLyIng/0ryVgZ78AgAJ) , 
and perhaps you will view me as one of those boo birds. However I do wish both 
initiatives all the very best and I hope something good can come of them. My 
main concern is that no one has yet solved the collective action problem. 

 

I also wish that Kathleen had answered this part of my question: “How many 
members of COAR are also members of cOAlition S?"

 

Richard Poynder

 

 

From: Glenn Hampson <[email protected] 
<mailto:[email protected]> > 
Sent: 20 April 2020 16:05
To: 'Kathleen Shearer' <[email protected] 
<mailto:[email protected]> >; [email protected] 
<mailto:[email protected]> ; [email protected] 
<mailto:[email protected]> ; 'Global Open Access List (Successor of 
AmSci)' <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]> >
Subject: RE: [SCHOLCOMM] Fostering Bibliodiversity in Scholarly Communications: 
A Call for Action

 

Hi Kathleen, Richard, 

Can I suggest another way to look at these questions? First some background. As 
you know, the Open Scholarship Initiative (OSI) is launching Plan A today ( 
<http://plan-a.world/> http://plan-a.world). Plan A is OSI’s 2020-25 action 
plan, representing five years of deep thinking that OSI participants have 
invested in the many questions related to the future of scholarly communication 
reform. 

Plan A looks at the “bibliodiversity” challenge a little differently. For OSI, 
diversity has also meant inclusion---listening to everyone’s ideas (including 
publishers), valuing everyone’s input, trying to develop a complete 
understanding of the scholarly communication landscape, and trying to reach a 
point where we can work together on common ground toward goals that serve all 
of us. 

We have found over the course of our work that most everyone in the scholarly 
communication community recognizes the same challenges on the road ahead, we 
all have the same needs, and we all suffer from the same inability to see the 
full picture ourselves and to make change by ourselves. Fulfilling the vision 
of bibliodiversity will mean valuing everyone’s perspective of and contribution 
to the scholarly communication system, and truly working together across our 
real and perceived divides to achieve, together, what is in the best interest 
of research and society.

OSI’s common ground paper provides a deeper look at this common ground and some 
of the approaches suggested by OSI participants. The summary version will be 
published soon by Emerald Open; for now, the full-length version is available 
under the resources tab of the Plan A website.

My short answer to your questions, Richard, about practical matters like how 
all this change is going to transpire and through what mechanisms, is that for 
us, this needs to be decided by Plan A signatories (and will be). This effort 
is designed to tie into UNESCO’s ongoing open science roadmap work (which OSI 
is helping with). UNESCO’s plan will be presented to the UN in late 2021. The 
longer answer is that the real value in this conversation will come as we 
“expand the pie.” This isn’t about looking for compromise positions between 
read-only access and read-reuse, or between zero and 6-month embargo periods. 
It’s about truly working together on common interests, and thinking through 
issues in a way we haven’t before as a community (in a large-scale, diverse, 
high level, policy-oriented sense). 

I expect our efforts will cross paths in the years ahead, Kathleen. We would be 
honored to collaborate and contribute to your work.

Best regards to you both,

Glenn

 

Glenn Hampson
Executive Director
 <x-msg://152/sci.institute> Science Communication Institute (SCI)
Program Director
 <x-msg://152/osiglobal.org> Open Scholarship Initiative (OSI)

 <x-msg://152/osiglobal.org> <image003.jpg>

 

 

From:  <mailto:[email protected]> [email protected] 
< <mailto:[email protected]> [email protected]> On 
Behalf Of Kathleen Shearer (via scholcomm Mailing List)
Sent: Monday, April 20, 2020 6:12 AM
To:  <mailto:[email protected]> [email protected];  
<mailto:[email protected]> [email protected]; Global Open Access 
List (Successor of AmSci) < <mailto:[email protected]> [email protected]>
Subject: Re: [SCHOLCOMM] Fostering Bibliodiversity in Scholarly Communications: 
A Call for Action

 

Hello Richard,

 

Yes, indeed, you are right, the coordinated actions required for 
bibliodiversity are similar to the efforts needed to deal with the covid19 
pandemic. 

 

For your second question, the way I am envisioning the collaborations taking 
place is as follows: much of the discussions across the different stakeholder 
communities will happen at the national and sometimes regional level, while the 
international coordination will take place, in parallel, within each different 
stakeholder community. Although not a perfect solution, because some countries 
are more cohesive than others, many communities already have fairly strong 
regional and international relationships with their peers, including scholarly 
societies, libraries, funders (e.g. the funders forum at RDA), governments, as 
well as publishers, and repositories.

 

1.       Are translation technologies adequate to the task envisaged for them 
in the document?

 

I’m not an expert on translation technologies, but my colleagues tell me that 
for some languages the technologies are quite far along already and work well 
(e.g. Spanish, French, Portuguese, Chinese), for others it will take a bit 
longer. They are suggesting a timeline for most languages to have fairly good 
translation tools available within the next 5 years.

 

3.       Might it be that the different interests and priorities of these 
stakeholders are such that joint action is not possible, certainly in a way 
that would satisfy all the stakeholders? After all, funders got involved with 
open access because after 20+ years the other stakeholders had failed to work 
together effectively. However, in doing so, these funders appear (certainly in 
Europe) to be pushing the world in a direction that the authors of this report 
deprecate. What, practically, can the movement do to achieve the aspirations of 
the document beyond making a call to action or further declarations?

 

The point of this call to action is to raise awareness with funders and others 
about this important issue. I’m not so cynical to think organizational 
perspectives can never change. Strategies can (and should) evolve as we gain a 
better understanding of the landscape, and adopt new ideas and principles. We 
hope that this call to action will have that type of impact.


And, yes of course not all interests will align, but we are already seeing more 
cohesiveness at the national level than in the past. In Canada, where I am 
based, for example, the funders, libraries and local Canadian publishers are 
now in regular dialogue and collaborating to work on common action items and to 
better align policies, funding and infrastructure. This is also happening in 
other jurisdictions such as France with its  
<https://www.ouvrirlascience.fr/the-committee-for-open-science/> Committee for 
Open Science and Portugal where the national funder, universities (including 
libraries and university presses) and scholarly societies have created and 
maintain a national infrastructure for Open Access (hosting repositories and 
journals) and aligned policies.

 

All the best, 

Kathleen

 

 

Kathleen Shearer

Executive Director

Confederation of Open Access Repositories (COAR)

 <http://www.coar-repositories.org/> www.coar-repositories.org

 

 

 

On Apr 16, 2020, at 1:31 AM, Richard Poynder < 
<mailto:[email protected]> [email protected]> wrote:

 

“Designing a system that fosters bibliodiversity, while also supporting 
research at the international level is extremely challenging. It means 
achieving a careful balance between unity and diversity; international and 
local; and careful coordination across different stakeholder communities and 
regions in order to avoid a fragmented ecosystem.”

 

That seems to me to be a key paragraph in this document. And the pandemic — 
which requires that information is shared very quickly and broadly, and across 
borders — does certainly highlight the fact that the current scholarly 
communication system leaves a lot to be desired. 

 

I have three questions:

 

1.       Are translation technologies adequate to the task envisaged for them 
in the document? 

 

2.       How is it envisaged that researchers, policymakers, funders, service 
providers, universities and libraries from around the world will all work 
together, and by means of what forum? I know there are a number of 
organisations and initiatives focused on the different issues raised in the 
document (not least COAR) but how exactly, and by what means, will these 
different stakeholders coordinate and work together to achieve the stated aims? 
I know there are a number of library-led organisations (like COAR), but is not 
a more diverse forum (in terms of the different stakeholders) needed? How many 
members of COAR are also members of cOAlition S for instance?

 

3.       Might it be that the different interests and priorities of these 
stakeholders are such that joint action is not possible, certainly in a way 
that would satisfy all the stakeholders? After all, funders got involved with 
open access because after 20+ years the other stakeholders had failed to work 
together effectively. However, in doing so, these funders appear (certainly in 
Europe) to be pushing the world in a direction that the authors of this report 
deprecate. What, practically, can the movement do to achieve the aspirations of 
the document beyond making a call to action or further declarations?

 

Richard Poynder 

 

 

On Wed, 15 Apr 2020 at 15:53, Kathleen Shearer < 
<mailto:[email protected]> [email protected]> wrote:

(Apologies for the cross posting)

Dear all,

Today, my colleagues and I are issuing a “Call for Action!”

With the publication of this paper,  
<https://www.coar-repositories.org/news-updates/fostering-bibliodiversity-in-scholarly-communications-a-call-for-action/>
 Fostering Bibliodiversity in Scholarly Communications: A Call for Action, we 
are calling on the community to make concerted efforts to develop strong, 
community-governed infrastructures that support diversity in scholarly 
communications (referred to as bibliodiversity).

Diversity is an essential characteristic of an optimal scholarly communications 
system. Diversity in services and platforms, funding mechanisms, and evaluation 
measures will allow the research communications to accommodate the different 
workflows, languages, publication outputs, and research topics that support the 
needs and epistemic pluralism of different research communities. In addition, 
diversity reduces the risk of vendor lock-in, which inevitably leads to 
monopoly, monoculture, and high prices.

We are living through unprecedented times, with a global pandemic sweeping the 
world, leading to illness, death, and unparalleled economic upheaval.  Although 
our concerns about bibliodiversity have been growing for years, the current 
crisis has exposed the deficiencies in a system that is increasingly homogenous 
and prioritizes profits over the public good.

Stories abound about the urgent need for access to the research literature, as 
illustrated, for example, by this message by Peter Murray-Rust  
<http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/pipermail/goal/2020-March/005395.html> posted 
to the GOAL mailing list on March 31, 2020

“My colleague, a software developer, working for free on openVirus software,  
is spending most of his time working making masks in Cambridge Makespace to 
ship to Addenbrooke’s hospital. When he goes to the literature to find 
literature on masks, their efficacy and use and construction he finds paywall 
after paywall after paywall after paywall ….”

For those who were not in favour of open access before, this global crisis 
should settle the debate once and for all.

We must move away from a pay-to-read world in which researchers, practitioners 
and the public cannot afford to access critical research materials, or have to 
wait for embargo periods to lift before they can develop life saving 
techniques, methods and vaccines. Access to the research is simply too 
important. Yet, pay-to-publish, the open access model being advanced by many in 
the commercial sector, is also inappropriate as it places unacceptable 
financial barriers on researchers’ abilities to publish.

It is time to reassess some of the basic assumptions related to scholarly 
communications, including competition, prestige, and the role of commercial 
entities. The same values that underlie our research and education systems 
should also guide research communications.

To that end, we are calling on researchers, policy makers, funders, service 
providers, universities and libraries from around the world to work together to 
address the issue of bibliodiversity in scholarly communication.

The problems we encounter have never been more complex and urgent, nor has the 
need for solutions been greater. There is a real danger that new budget 
constraints and an increasing proportion of funds directed towards large 
commercial entities could lead to greater homogeneity and monopolization, 
further hampering the free flow of research needed to address the critical 
challenges we face.

Read the  
<https://www.coar-repositories.org/news-updates/fostering-bibliodiversity-in-scholarly-communications-a-call-for-action/>
 blog post here and  <http://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3752923> full paper here

 

Kathleen Shearer

Executive Director

Confederation of Open Access Repositories (COAR)

 <http://www.coar-repositories.org/> www.coar-repositories.org

 

 

 




 

-- 

Richard Poynder

 

 


  _____  

[1]. OSI is such a group but our design is to share information and 
perspectives, not be a deliberative body focused on developing solutions.

 

_______________________________________________
GOAL mailing list
[email protected]
http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal

Reply via email to