Hey Mohit, I am really happy you had your second honeymoon at the Cidade de 
Goa. 
Yes, it is a pretty nice place isn't it? Neo-Goan-Modernist architecture of 
Charles 
Correia, beautifully and even tastefully maintained.

But that beach on which the hotel is built, that was public way, way before, 
when I 
was in college. My mother has a house close by, and it has been a high point of 
my 
life visiting the beach, and forcing the hotel to open the chain blocking 
public 
access to the beach. I've seen Goan beaches right through college, and the 
Goans 
themselves never littered them. That came in the late 70s when the hotels 
(owned by 
non_goans) came up, and with them Indian tourists on the honeymoons, who wanted 
the 
bhel-puri carts and all the other junk that makes a chowpatti a chowpatti.

It is just not true that one can casually walk to the beach, although guys like 
me 
who insisted in talking to the GM and getting the piublic access opened were 
offered 
this bad-tasting carrot. (Samir, perhaps you should send Mohit, some of 
Advocate 
Norma Alvares' article on this case she won). Oh, I have also attached the 
'Cidade 
Ordinance' as it is now being termed...that legalizes the illegalities so to 
speak 
and, overturn  the Supreme Court verdict. The hotel is open to you again, just 
the 
way you know it...

Sure Baga sucks, I haven't been there for 15 years now, even though my 
ancestral 
home, is barely three kilometres away as the crow flies. You must see this in 
context though. In Goa, we have been witness to corruption between industry and 
government for the last thirty years, starting with The Fort Aguada Beach 
Resort and 
Zuari Agro Chemicals, one which 'privatised' a beach and took over a hill, the 
other 
that happily polluted traditional wells in the village of Sancoale.

It is not my intention to meticulously note the many trangressions of law, and 
the 
appropriations of what one call only call the 'commons' by unscrupulous 
businesses. 
Men like you I suspect, will see this as the work of a person who writes crap, 
or 
who gives 'fart' because he has time on his hands. The company that owns the 
Cidade 
de Goa made its money by destroying forests and aquifers in the Western Ghats 
in 
their greed for iron ore. That is an ongoing agitation. Do you know that the 
Timblos 
start mining before they even get their so-called 'environment clearances'?

One suspects that in far less jest and sarcasm, you would have strongly 
endorsed the 
Supreme Court ruling that gave Vedanta the right to destroy Oriisa's forests 
and 
displace the tribals living there for centuries. As Damian Grammaticus showed, 
the 
Adivasis were saying that the forests and hills were their Gods, the tribals 
worshipped them.

When we break the nexus between industry and government in Goa, and maybe 
conscientize people enough so that they place voluntary limits on their wants 
ansd 
sometimes greed, I have strong reason to believe that Goa will be the place you 
can 
have your third honeymoon in. But before that, you will please not take the 
perhaps 
involuntary position that Goa is only a place for the well-heeled to chill out. 
The 
same company that owns the beautifully landscaped Cidade de Goa, even as this 
is 
being written, is happily destroying the foothills of the Western Ghats in the 
south-east.

If you had been following the groundswell of the thinking Goan public, I 
suspect you 
would be sensitive enough to put your weight behind us, thereby ensuring a more 
beautiful Goa for all of us.

But then again, for guys like you, Goa, or what you choose to see of it, is 
beautiful right now. When the Timblos decide the mining has much more value and 
starts mining the plateau adjacent to the hotel, you'll probably move to the 
Maldives for your trysts with romance. If that, thanks to the rising levels of 
the 
sea goes under, you'll move to Bali. If there's bombings there, you'll move to 
Surinam or Puerto Rico. Trinidad may not be such a good place, because Essar 
Steel 
plan to build a steel mill there!

It's not just a question of a bloody luxury resort!

Cheers,

Hartman 


Reply via email to