--- On Tue, 5/19/09, Gilbert Lawrence <gilbert2...@yahoo.com> wrote:
>
> Goanet atheists have pounded us into submission with their
> claim that church-going was a wasted activity, generally
> undertaken by those with no cognitive function. :=))
> 

Is Gilbert telling the truth here, or is he making something up from faulty 
memory? Has Kevin or someone else ever made the above claim? Confabulation 
because of faulty memory is a sign of cognitive dysfunction, which 
unfortunately many of us cannot escape irrespective of whether we go to the 
church, temple, bar or the night club.

Another cognitive mishap in what Gilbert wrote is that he has truncated Mario's 
statement to change its meaning in his following quote:

"You continue to tickle me pink, by once again assuring us that "church going, 
create positive and healthy mental attitude which is what is behind the 
beneficial effects.""
....Gilbert Lawrence

Please see Mario's statement below:

"If one lacks cognitive function to begin with going to church is hardly likely 
to create what is missing. What I was suggesting was that there are likely to 
be many social activities, in addition to church going, that create the 
positive and healthy mental attitude which is what is behind the beneficial 
effects."
....Mario Goveia

Cheers,

Santosh




Reply via email to