On Mon, 5 Jan 2026 08:49:36 +0000 Helge wrote:
> GNU Smalltalk differs from the main Smalltalk dialects significantly

and/but OTOH and IIRC, GNU Smalltalk is the nearest to the ANSI dialect, which
is actually the stronger formalized concept of a standard - a standard has more
of the character of "main-ness" than ordinary organic dialects

if one takes "main" to be "the most standardized or interoperable" then GNU
Smalltalk is actually the best match for a "main Smalltalk dialect"; so it
would be remiss not to mention that perhaps ironic twist

presumably, the quoted use of "main" is a measure of popularity (eg: number of
installs) rather than of technical similarity or heritage, or the domain of some
authority, or otherwise what people usually mean by "main-line"

the smalltalks are best described a language zoo - none qualify or deserve such
a badge of "main-ness", nor "de-facto", nor so on - a IRL zoo would not present
one animal as the main animal, though some may be favorites of some or other
visitors

Reply via email to