--__--__--
Message: 3
From: "Tony \"omega\" Sergi" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: [hlcoders] Re: People crying about changes to CS:S custom,
network protocol (Michael A. Hobson)
Date: Sun, 22 May 2005 14:27:13 -0400
Reply-To: [email protected]
My $.02.
Even though this has already been said by 3 diff people:
Quote:
I should point out that whilst yes I am using the network message
protocol to generate the in game menus there is nowhere in the code that
says 'Dont use this'.
:End Quote.
right, it doesn't say don't use it in the SDK source code. And, to be
blatantly obvious as others have said, you have to be a complete moron to
think that everything in the SDK is "okay to use" for **all** mods. Valve,
Alfred, and others have already said, plain as a clear blue cloudless sky
"use API functions for cross-mod compatibility, and don't rely on per-mod
hacks as not all mods are going to be the same". (<-- my wording.)
Now what I get out of that is simply: if you're going to hook into something
that can and probably will change on a per mod basis, you have no right to
bitch when that said item changes, when you were told in the first place not
to do it. if you chose to ignore that, you are the stereotypical moron who
chose not to heed direction in the first place.
With that said, sure, maybe you guys weren't told from the day one "don't
use menuselect with CS:S plugins because we will be changing that in the
future". You really think valve wants to spend the extra time notifying all
plugin authors of every possible change to a mod that could affect plugins
not using the plugin api the way it's supposed to be used? If if you chose
not to use it the way it was designed then it's your own fault for it to
break when something changes. As it was with metamod in hl1. I don't recall
people bitching then when something changed in the mods, oh, right, because
it wasn't valve maintaining it?
I'm not bitching about anything :)
I already provide identical functionality using the Valve API functions
for cross mod compatibility so it's not like my 6 months of work is down
the drain. In fact I don't have to do anything other than tell CSS
admins to change a cvar in the plugin configuration if they haven't already.
It was only CSS that could ever use the radio style menus and have them
work, we only ever used them because they work well from within the
game, hack or not.
I'm all for a standard GUI API that is cross mod dependant as it saves
us work. Imagine having to re-code your menu system for every single mod
that will come off the back of the source engine, not fun.
Mani
_______________________________________________
To unsubscribe, edit your list preferences, or view the list archives, please
visit:
http://list.valvesoftware.com/mailman/listinfo/hlcoders