What he means to say is that in the world of musicians tradition is often
what people fall back on and anything new and unconventional is typically
frowned upon.
People rely on the methods that 'work for them' and 'have always worked' or
'because it's what my teacher/professional musicians do'. Seldom are the
methods questioned, and often are the methods only used out of tradition.
There is a lot of repetition in the world of professional music, and a lot of
heredity which is carried with each musician.
So, when one offers up another point of view it's not just opposing views
that clash - it's the entire heredity or the entire career or going against
what 'obviously' works. In other words, if someone hears an opposing view
point, it's not just an opposing view point. It's an opposition to their
career, their personality, and their teaching.
We've seen this many times in other fields, but it is overly common in the
world of music. How many composers and musicians have tried to do new
things only to let the general establishment ignore it in favor of what was
always done?
How many of us who rely on traditions can ask ourselves why and give
ourselves an objective answer?
What a lot of musicians fail to realize is that a lot of the valued aspects
within the world of music are rarely objective ('musicianship', 'soul')
and is based a lot on subjectivity. And, when objective methods are attempted
to be applied by anyone, it's a natural tendency to find any excuses to
why they won't work. It's sort of an all or nothing/black or white mentality
at times.
Of course what I say here is going to be met with a lot of negativity, and
I will be the first to admit that I've been guilty of the same things and
often have to take a step or two back and realize that life goes on.
But I'm not the only person who notices this in musicians. We also must
remember that music (while important to us) is not high on the list of
necessities for civilization. Finally, we must all remember (including myself)
that being an expert in one field does not make us an expert on life - and
that we should remain humble and intellectually honest as much as we can.
-William
In a message dated 11/27/2009 4:09:48 P.M. Eastern Standard Time,
[email protected] writes:
Joshua, if you like to play the entire solo repertoire at double than
normal speed and obnoxious loud, you should better remain in this other world,
as such behavior would clearly "piss-off" (sorry !) most of the serious
players.
_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org