It's probably better to keep the biology discussion off of the list - but  
there really isn't all that much difference between us and the rest of the 
great  apes.
 
Also, with regards to the 'who ignited it' argument - that resorts to the  
cosmological argument and has a lot of problems. And why do you assume I 
would  go to a religious argument? 
 
Assumptions assumptions. Not everyone in America is a fundamentalist (or  
even religious) you know.
 
Funny how you mention though that the E fingerings aren't a problem, then  
when I bring in the 3rd finger issue the goalposts switch to "well you don't 
use  it that often anyway!". 
 
Seems to me you're doing everything in your power to ignore using it as  
well - we just have two different approaches.
 
If it works for both of us - why should there be any argument?
 
-William
 
 
In a message dated 11/28/2009 7:40:17 A.M. Eastern Standard Time,  
[email protected] writes:

Sorry  again, what you wrote is mere sophistery. 

What keeps us really  different to other organism in the universe ???? Our 
brain and philosophy  (including the different religions) and art of all 
kind, which includes road  construction, house construction, math formulas, 
nuclear technique, writing,  reading, composing, painting, sculpturing etc. - I 
admit, some animals   are able to create some primitive art from their own 
fantasy & their own  selection of colors, after they have received the 
training how to hold the  brush & how to put color on the plate, cloth or 
paper. 
Have you seen  elephants or monkeys paint ? Surely. But these are the 
extreme rare  exceptions. And language is what separates us from animals. And 
arts 
is a very  old companion of mankind, perhaps oldest example "Venus of 
Willendorf",  perhaps from 30.000 years ago. Willendorf is just 60 miles of my 
home town.  Real man started with the development of the language & with the 
desire to  leave some tracks (sculptures, paintings). Music has been volatile 
until  musical notation came into use, the other abstract besides math. As 
the  majority of mankind is unable to decipher musical notation - or 
unwilling to  learn that - it has been a secret still, how we can bring it to 
live. 
But it  works since hundreds of years. Animals or other living organisms 
cannot do  that. They also cannot bring life top the written word or 
understand sketches  or paintings. This is really a separation of man & animal.

Yes, you  are right with your given percentage, but - just looking at the 
animal and  plant world - are not over 90% of all living creatures plants & 
insects or  primitive organisms in the sea ?? Did you also calculate the 
"viral" world  ?

The big apes have a social life as have the elephants. All mating  animals 
have a sense for better appeal (brighter colors, strength).  

You are right, talking about the technical aspect of life. But isn´t  all 
life more or less based on H2O and N ??? Yes, and you might say all  
developed from there, and I might go further, who created all that & who  
ignited it 
? Do not come now with the religious thing. It would not fit your  
technical approach.

And this thing with the third finger ? Even in the  E-pieces the third 
finger is involved just here & there. It is the same  problem for many players 
as the use of the thumb valve (trigger) as an equal  valve, even in the 
middle of an exposed scale, just to get better intonation.  Well, that´s 
professional talk from professional experience, playing the horn  for several 
hours 
daily, but not alone, but in the orchestra.

That is  not looking down upon amateurs or advanced or experienced amateurs 
with proper  studies, that is just "reality thinking" from my side.

Do not take all  as just directed to your person. My messages are directed 
to the community.  But I though being courteous by addressing you by  name.

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
+


Am  28.11.2009 um 08:39 schrieb [email protected]:

> Assumptions,  assumptions, assumptions.
> 
> You assume for starters that I  think music doesn't play an important 
role  
> in my life. You're  wrong. I frankly never said this.
> 
> What I did say are the arts  are not a necessity in life. They do not 
even  
> exist for >  99.99% of all organisms in this world (or even the solar 
system  
>  since we now have evidence thanks to NASA that there was once bacterial  
> life on  Mars).
> 
> The arts are not separates us  from chimpanzees. What separates us is a  
> fusion of two  chromosomes and opposable thumbs, etc. The great apes do 
have a  
>  concept of aesthetic appeal and they do have a concept of shapes and  
form.  
> They're not as dumb as you think. Are they at the level  of 
sophistication in 
> terms of a 'civilized' society? No.
>  
> Like it or not, if there was full thermonuclear exchange and we had  to 
save 
> a select group of people musicians would not be at the top of  the list. 
We 
> are  the hired help most of the time. We are most  of the time not looked 
on 
> as equals  when compared to the upper  echelons of society. Society 
doesn't 
> function off of  art and  music. Art and music are the window dressing. 
They 
> don't sweep  the  streets. They don't build the roads. They don't carry 
our 
>  sewage away from our  houses.
> 
> You also assume that  (because I'm American perhaps) that I seldom use 
the F 
> side of the  horn. In fact, I use it frequently in the high tessitura for 
>  many  reasons. Am I a pro? No. But I'm no slouch either. 
>  
> So I'm not sure why you posted a paragraph of Bb usage on  selected  
> non-sequence notes when the subject was really around  faster passages 
with E  horn 
> fingerings and the third finger  having tendon issues. 
> 
> Try the combination switch from 2 to 1  and 3 and back and forth. I  
> guarantee you won't be able to do  it as fast as you can do something 
like 2 to  12 
> or 1 to 12 or  even 1 to 2. All the alternate fingerings in the world 
won't  
>  fix that (and there aren't enough anyway). 
> 
> -William
>  
> 
> In a message dated 11/28/2009 2:25:18 A.M. Eastern Standard  Time,  
> [email protected] writes:
> 
> Sorry,  very  sorry William. 
> 
> Doesn´t music play a most important role in  our  life ? You deny it. But 
if 
> you listen around, there is  music everywhere &  at any time & in any 
mode. 
> Answering  machines, supermarkets, shopping  malls, festivity tents, 
parties,  
> radio, TV, announcements - music is there. I  do not talk about  concert 
> music. But isn´t there a lot of music in the halls,   named churches by 
the 
> different religions ? And the dancing  halls  ?
> 
> Music is one thing, which distinguishes men  from monkey. Music is  part 
of 
> our culture. Music of any  kind.
> This stated first.
> 
> We had  the combination  F/Bb in history, say in the time of the natural 
> horn, pairing   horns of complementary key (matching key, to make more 
notes 
>  available or  using the other horn to get a better output for important  
notes).
> 
> For  the Weber op.45 it would make sense &  make things (fingerings) much 
> easier  tuning the horn down to  E/A & play (finger) the part in F. But 
what 
> happen  under  stress, we could notice in a world wide broadcasted (incl. 
TV) 
>  concert  several months ago. Even your method may convince, why not  
returning 
> to the  old & simple method:
> 
> play  F, where appropriate & play Bb, where  it fits or be necessary.  
> Anything different (except the descant for special  tasks) may  just 
confuse (under 
> stress). This has the advantage, that you  get  more endurance, but if 
you 
> get tired, you can stiil switch  to the Bb-side to  arrive "still alive" 
at 
> the end of the  piece.
> 
> As the Weber op.45 (to  remain with the example)  is not an extreme high 
> concerto, but in the middle  range  mostly, it is easily mastered by 
using the 
> F-side & involving  the  2nd finger a lot of time, but switching to the 
>  Bb-side  occasionally.
> 
> First page: Bb-use: (perhaps,  played note): M.11 entrance  with g2, M.18 
> also g2 after a jump,  M.20 same, after "Con fuoco" the f#2 in  M.76, 80, 
88, 
> the  entire passage M.130-132, the g2 M.151, the e2 M.153 (after  the 
high  
> jump), the g2 in M.155 (Cadenza), same M.156 perhaps, the high a  in  
M.162, the 
> Polacca: f#2 in M.180, same M.196,  same  M.212 & 214, the  high g#2 in 
> M.233, 235, 237,241; the  passage M.246 until the lower b-nat.  (even 
with an 
> accent &  for better response), the entrance g2 in M.250 (for  easy & 
light  
> response), the f#2 in M.275 (big jump), the entire M.297 (for   clarity), 
the low 
> b-nat. in M.299 & the high b-nat. held, high g2  in  M.302, the gä2 in 
> M.304, all notes frm M.307 to the f#2 in  the next M.,  perhaps the g#2 
in M.312, 
> the high b-nat in M.316,  the f#2 in M.332 (only),  but the low b-nat in 
> M.333 (for better  response) followed by the arpeggio up  to high b-nat 
(still on 
>  the F-side) to jump up to high Eb3 by help of the  "jumper key", the  
> Bb-trigger (like kicking oneself in the back !).
> 
>  That  simple. But it requires a full re-thinking of the use of the  
double, 
> as a  mainly used F-horn with the possibility to switch  to the Bb-side 
for 
> special  required assistance or better  intonation or expression or 
response.
> 
> I  know, that is  against the main path, but it worked fine for me until  
>  retirement and it costed me less nerves & less "super concentration".  
One  
> should avoid everything not absolutely necessary, when  performing, as 
our  
> instrument as any other instrument requires  more concentration upon the  
> accuracy of the notes & the  expression & the tone quality. And not  
every 
> interesting  piece might fit for every player, no matter how  skilled.
>  
> Finally, we must distinguish between music (controlled or   regulated 
noise) 
> and mere noise (blaring loud, uncontrolled  noise,  environmental  noise).
> 
>  
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
>  +++++    
> 
>  _______________________________________________
> post:   [email protected]
> unsubscribe or set options at  
>  
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/valkhorn%40aol.com
>  
> _______________________________________________
> post:  [email protected]
> unsubscribe or set options at  
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/hpizka%40me.com

_______________________________________________
post:  [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at  
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/valkhorn%40aol.com

_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to