This debate is getting rather lengthy (and I'm sure no one else is interested). To save time, let's just leave it that we will agree to disagree. Like I say, you have your way and I have mine. I doubt we'll ever agree so that's that. As for the tuning, it will work for a majority of players/horns - but this lies within the realm of "tradition/my teacher always told me" etc. so don't confuse it being accepted with it not working. -William In a message dated 11/29/2009 2:07:12 A.M. Eastern Standard Time, [email protected] writes:
If the horn (doublehorn) is played in the "orthodox" way, the use of the third finger is necessary only for the "g#" on both sides & the "c#" on the Bb-side, whereof it is not necessary for the g#1 & g#2 on the Bb-side, if the harmonic is on the right place, so to be fingered as 2. If one plays a regular double horn, one will not play the low "eb" (below staff) on the F-side, because it would be too sharp, also the low "c#". And we have the Bb-side here to compensate this defect. If you claim, that the third finger is involved more, then you should know, that the classic horn method does not require 23 for any "eb" on the F-side except the low "eb" below staff. All other "eb" be played by "2" only. And the "d" within the staff are with "1" or "0" (the upper "d"). All other use is with alternated fingerings only, which confuse anyway when under stress situation. Ooops, I forgot the high "c3", where the "23" works superb on the F-side, better than any other. And a general word about using this most prolonged horn (D on the F-Side): it responds rather clumsy anyway because of the length of the tube. It does matter less on the Bb-side, as it be G-horn just, which is a tube of fine responding length. Please, what kind of math is involved when counting the rests, except simple counting, which is done by players "using their fingers & both hands": 1-2-3-4 -- 2-2-3-4 -- 3-2-3-4. Does the common musician really calculate mathematically how the pitches are related each other. It is interesting to know the facts, off course, but it does not help for the playing. I oppose your statement below. We landed on the moon because of Schumann. How ? Because we developed our brain to composing music, to incorporate complex acoustic sensations to abstract writings. How developed must the brain be to be able to imagine (hear) sounds, while just reading a classical (I am not talking about Classic period but about the assembly of a score & classic notation) score ? Very developed, very developed. So this development enabled us to go to space. The abstract thinking. If you look at Schumann, to remain with your example, if you look to Schumann just particularly, you might just find your argument. Music is no superstition, but it might be interesting, how the number of followers to all esoteric & superstition is growing all over the world, but how fast common knowledge is decreasing throughout the world. So I applaud your statement about the importance understanding how the world function. But music or the other arts are equal important as they are human expressions which serve best as communication tool between the different nations & cultures. Music is the universal language. You can see it as pure math, off course also. You said, that you prefer the shorter horn. Yes, there we are. These "sports models" require the use of the third finger a lot more than regular horns. But this is not how the majority of horn players uses the instrument. The full double is still the major instrument. Yes, I can paint my house even without owning the house. I can paint & decorate it at best at the computer and build later. Still, German engineering (from theory: building all on paper or screen first & decide how it must be done) is different from other countries engineering (empiric: trying how it works, trying how it fits). All what you said about your tuning etc. will surely fit for your situation, but not for the majority. Even interesting, it will fit just those using a comparable equipment. Here on the list, we shall rather talk about things for the majority of players. ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ++ Am 28.11.2009 um 23:00 schrieb [email protected]: > There are many 3rd finger notes as you've explained. There's also the 1 to > 2 combinations as well. > > I have tried playing it in an A/E horn and I didn't like it because I > preferred a shorter horn. I thought I had explained that? > > But it is strange how some people on the list claim knowledge of math and > science is useless for Horn playing. If math is so useless then how do they > count. If science is so useless you might as well be guessing what you're > doing in terms of intonation and acoustics. Science is the best tool we have > right now to objectively find the truth. The proof is in the pudding. We > didn't land on the moon by performing Schumann. > > Am I completely right 100% of the time? No. There were a few things about > acoustics I wasn't aware of. However nothing that the experts in this field > have said have detracted from my tuning method either. I'm also not the > only person who uses this method either. > > You may think understanding more about how the world works is useless - but > I don't. And as for civilization - it counts on this knowledge. The real > world isn't going to progress with superstition/tradition/magic. It is only > going to improve/progress with rational/logical discourse. This is why > music/arts (while important to some degree) are always going to be secondary to > the fundamentals. > > After all, how are you going to paint/decorate a house if you haven't even > built it? > > Again, your way works for you. My way works for me. That's that. > > -William > _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/valkhorn%40aol.com _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
