> The solo is very simple and right in the easiest register of the horn
> (all notes between 1st line E to 4th line D). In other words, there's
> room for even weekend horn player to pour some feeling into the solo
> as there are neither treacherous leaps nor extreme range and/or volume
> issues. So what did our DVD soloist (shown in close-up as he played)
> do?
>
> He played the WHOLE THING on the Bb side of his double horn.
>
> Sometimes, when you know someone is being paid 150-thousand+ per year
> to play principal horn, you just want to see him (or her) "step up to
> the plate" and show he got the job by playing musically, instead of
> winning the audition because he "didn't miss any notes."
>

If playing a solo on the F side rather than the Bb side is your definition
of musicality, then I have to say I have little interest in ever hearing you
play.

I don't care two hoots which side of the horn a passage is played on. A
decent player should be able to get sounds out of both sides that are more
or less indistinguishable from each other, so that he can treat the two
sides just as fingering options allowing him to obtain optimal tuning and
smoothness of slurring.

The musicality comes from making good decisions about phrasing,
articulation, dynamics and note placement, as well as having sufficient
technical mastery of the instrument to be able to execute all that with
impeccable tuning and a beautiful tone.

Regards
Jonathan West
_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to