It really does not matter, what type of horn is in the hands of a real artist. Peter Damm (73 in a few days) was a Bb-horn artist, but practised on the F-horn. But he produced wonderful music on his Bb-horn. He really sang the horn, but he could play extremely powerful also, when necessary.
Well, myself, I grew up with the hand horn & the Viennese Pumpenhor, even using it during my audition for Gerd Seiferts job in Duesseldorf. What a fine ppp last concert a (Siegfried Call last echo) when 1st bvalv half pressed. Yes, my use of the double later, became something very particular, as I used the trigger back & forth where necessary to produce better intonation for some notes (even middle in a scale), to get a better attack, or use it as a turbo gear with "after-burner" for e.g. Zarathustra or some Bruckner or Wagner, but never for a full page or full piece. If the fingering was easier on the Bb-side, I used it, no matter high or low range. Why risking your neck in a delicate piece, playing in a high grade orchestra ? Nonsense. It is not cowardness, by no means. It is responsibility. Listen to my Aria from Guilio Cesare, all on the single high-F, but extremely light sung, better than on any Bb-horn. I also did J.S.Bachs Missa solo on a single F, a Viennese but with rotary valves, even with Karl Richter conducting. D-major fingering was much easier on the F-Horn, - and the sound colour matches better with the singer. You just need a safe "a" above the staff (concert d). And the Strauss Lieders: well, a good amateur player might do it without a problem, but at home, behind the oven or in the bathroom or the basement. Playing it in a professional concert on tour e.g. or at home requires more than just playing the right notes at the right time & observing the expression marks. It must sound like an equal partner to the soprano, entering into her mood, colouring the horns sound like the female voice, - and creating the same tears in the eyes of the listeners & the colleagues playing or sitting with you in the orchestra. Feeling cannot be measured. Brain activity in certain centers of the brain can be measured. But what does this say ? Is there any way to translate this to numbers ? Surely not, except brain activity. And all the feeling, the emotions are acquired by education in the family (missed today mostly), by the environment (school, media, books, accumulated datas in the brain through experiences of life, etc., partners, great conductors, great recordings - well, this is talking music only, but it is related to every aspect of life !!). etc.etc. It is good to have technician pushing our development further, but they should not think, they can do everything. Yes, I agree, they can copy more things than we might imagine. But there a lot of people out, who are able to imagine the future or parts of it. When we travelled to Japan 1974 (the orchestra), I had my brand new single 8 camera with me & I told my colleagues, we will not have any moving parts on future film cameras except focussing know, or some buttons. They called me insane, they could not imagine how it would work without a film. I told them, how I imagined the function. We have them now. We still we cannot create humans. We just can produce "inhuman" or "antihuman" robots. ##################################################################################### Am 12.07.2010 um 15:08 schrieb [email protected]: > What about Peter Damm? He almost exclusively plays on a single Bb. > > A lot of the greats played extensively on single Bbs. > > -William > > > > > > > > > > > -----Original Message----- > From: [email protected] > To: [email protected] > Sent: Mon, Jul 12, 2010 8:54 am > Subject: [Hornlist] Robots & Bb Horn (was: "About those brass > playing robots...") > > >> Concerts have become boring anyway, as most orchestra miss the > >> particular character. All sound the same (like robots). > > > > > > I would like to disagree with Herr Pizka, but I cannot. > > > > At a friend's house recently, I watched a DVD of a MAJOR BIG-TIME > > orchestra doing Strauss's 'Four Last Songs' with a famous soprano. > > During the "September" movement, Strauss wrote a beautiful horn solo > > for us, one that, at once, sums up all that went before it, and > > promises us a beautiful ending to follow. > > > > The solo is very simple and right in the easiest register of the horn > > (all notes between 1st line E to 4th line D). In other words, there's > > room for even weekend horn player to pour some feeling into the solo > > as there are neither treacherous leaps nor extreme range and/or volume > > issues. So what did our DVD soloist (shown in close-up as he played) > > do? > > > > He played the WHOLE THING on the Bb side of his double horn. > > > > Sometimes, when you know someone is being paid 150-thousand+ per year > > to play principal horn, you just want to see him (or her) "step up to > > the plate" and show he got the job by playing musically, instead of > > winning the audition because he "didn't miss any notes." > > > > If you want to see what I'm talking about in action, on YouTube there > > is a video of Herr Pizka playing a solo from a Bruckner symphony (if > > memory serves). He plays mainly F-horn, and dips in and out of the Bb > > side only when it is PRUDENT to do so. Watch his fingers, it's all > > there as a lesson for us. > > > > I'm nobody in particular, and I've played entire concerts (as > > principal... say, maybe I AM somebody!) on the F-side of my double. In > > a recent Grieg piano concerto performance with a world-renowned > > pianist, I never touched the trigger. It's a piece that practically > > begs you to play F horn as, like the Strauss solo above, it's written > > right in the "sweet spot." There's nothing to do but press the buttons > > and pour on lots of soul. > > > > No, F horn is not my "religion," it's just that horn in the key of F > > is what most of the great composers had in their head as they wrote > > for us. In Mahler's 5th, I'll use the trigger quite often, but not all > > the time. In Brahms, there are long passages of F-horn only, but then > > there are also beautiful 3rd horn parts where, except for the very > > accomplished, employing the trigger is the most prudent action. > > > > The horn soloist on the DVD sounded fine, but he missed a great > > opportunity to display his mastery of his instrument. I mean, REALLY! > > Playing the written 1st space F on the open Bb side? Why? > > > > This is not a rant, but more of an exhortation for players to work on > > the F-side when possible. Of course, the first job is to not hit clams > > so, if you are unable to play a solo, in public, on the F-side, then > > by all means, use the trigger to save the performance. But when you > > get back to the practice room, THAT is the time to move your thumb > > away from the trigger and try setting your standards just a little > > higher. After a period of adjustment, perhaps it is you who will be > > impressing me on your next television broadcast. > > > > The preceding has been a public service announcement. In case of an > > actual emergency, you will be instructed to stand by your radio with > > your Pumpenhorn at hand. That is all. > > > > ADiF > > _______________________________________________ > > post: [email protected] > > unsubscribe or set options at > https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/valkhorn%40aol.com > > > > _______________________________________________ > post: [email protected] > unsubscribe or set options at > https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/hpizka%40me.com _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
