-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 Hi, Bryce:
Thanks for sharing. My comments inline. On 19/03/15 19:34, Bryce Nesbitt wrote: > I think the concerns are: > > 1) Will each mapper use the same keys, and if they misspell > something, will that be caught? All users will use the same keys. They will be presented with 4 keys: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import_Borno_eHealth_Africa_Smaller_Settlements#Tagging_Plans Of those tags, they will: a) Change the place=* tag for each node in each task of the TM project according to the size of the settlement against aerial imagery: place=hamlet, place=village, place=isolated_dwelling, place=neighbourhood b) Delete the fixme tag for each node. c) They aren't going to misspell anything. They are only adviced to check the spelling to put all nouns with the first letter capital, if it is not yet like that (almost all are already ok). > 2) How will future updates be "conflated" or brought into OSM? I don't know. And we don't need to know. There isn't any request for this when importing data. But as Frederik said, and I agree, when importing data is a good idea that data will somewhat be kept updated in the future. I only say that eHealth Africa is updating their data constantly, so it's possible that we could make future imports that add new settlement nodes, and modify/correct some of the already imported nodes. How this import would be done for the case of settlement nodes, it's not something I can answer now, but it's irrelevant for what we are discussing. Maybe it could be done using a similar manual import through the TM, or a semiautomatic one, or other. But in case me or you or whoever would like to do that import in the future, we would discuss it here in the imports list. I am sure that everyone here wants to do any import with sufficient guarantees and professionality. And that's why I ask for feedback. > 3) Will duplicates be caught (data already in OSM)? Already answered. That would be a matter of another different import, not this one. > 4) What tags and values, specifically, will be part of this > import. Already explained, but schematically: name=* place=* source=ehealthafrica.org And the changeset tags: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import_Borno_eHealth_Africa_Smaller_Settlements#Changeset_Tags > Past HOT type imports have brought huge quantities of keys that > were badly spelled, fragile, quickly out of date, and not > actionable or useful. there have been many imports of HOT. I only organized/was responsible of a part of them. Could you give me an example, what keys were low quality/out of date/not useful, and why? I can only be accountable for HOT imports that I organized, not of imports I am not. Cheers, Rafael. - -- Twitter: http://twitter.com/ravilacoya - -------------------------------- Por favor, non me envíe documentos con extensións .doc, .docx, .xls, .xlsx, .ppt, .pptx, aínda podendoo facer, non os abro. Atendendo á lexislación vixente, empregue formatos estándares e abertos. http://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenDocument#Tipos_de_ficheros -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.4.10 (GNU/Linux) Comment: Using GnuPG with undefined - http://www.enigmail.net/ iQIcBAEBAgAGBQJVCya5AAoJEB3niTly2pPQ0lYP/1eaFb1LL2rgN6tXtUZyU8n7 Of05/QdAZrkdDEbNZjHCLXFnx/qLJFJsnsYaQufmQMWVxDiqhVrUzyMaHQtdBS2D q/EsgHKpaCfUYTT1OSMTQt0PunMSri+lAZvPimdBleVx/WYFfyVP2mfgdIFOU8UM 8eKBV2IDBLFU5h9Uz+SlVV1izm33+Cm/2m8N7ACbwLzKuS9zx7lukwuIBi37HeIJ a2GDr9A2rnhnkASlWWStqS+9QPqOoTMkTULR4sVRvNjeG6lJdziYiIZngrykzPkL v9aqK1o2QrO9MQIYn3qKYtPLkUsI4ern3AciOFeyCGnScRroY5SPa/94ct6wY+YX Tot7eCk2T0rsPRT6GH/rCxUW1QSuUmMKZBqg10qjX34Lsw7IjNh62xpc/y5HpDhb OPplsoc8acH+UiKCPupxmL7R+MGg9MlEy8tzmlFDOg34ECmfV8TnlyIS+5ERZq9s OpOylP6cBPpYBLQxwhRx7aqJQxdsUFtnn7iT6URZhwmIQNzdY3AHFickTRRO1iod xxffYX7vytvis7FXG1M2nG/do8WSY6Jo/1hSXcALE/1FAv2uIsC8gzlTsKFMGAjQ 8gPQNZE9rX3Zofl7De2laM4s68zWrjxqWJUlig36xbF9EdGc9f5/nY3zqYd+obvO gE3uxfAtMd/epFgyl4sq =J8r8 -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- _______________________________________________ Imports mailing list Imports@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/imports