On Mon 2015-05-11 16:42:37, Knut Büscher wrote: > ############################ English text (german version below the > english text) ############################ > > Hi all, > > in February, I informed the OSM community via imports@openstreetmap.org > and talk...@openstreetmap.org about plans to update german "Aral" petrol > stations using a semi-automated process based on BP petrol station data. > > See https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Updating_german_Aral_petrol_stations > > After starting this process, I realized the need for detailed > examinations of the existing OSM petrol station objects in order to > match the BP data properly. So the process of matching german BP petrol > station data with existing OSM objects (amenity=fuel) took way longer > than expected. In the end, *8 out of 2.346 petrol stations listed in the > BP data file were identified as missing in OSM* (instead of > 420 > stations based on the initial estimation). Because these are only 8 > objects, I add the content of the corresponding .osm file to this email: > > <?xml version='1.0' encoding='UTF-8'?> > <osm version='0.6' upload='false' generator='JOSM'> > <node id='-20' action='modify' visible='true' lat='51.484392' > lon='6.975836'> > <tag k='addr:city' v='Essen' /> > <tag k='addr:country' v='DE' /> > <tag k='addr:housenumber' v='298a' /> > <tag k='addr:postcode' v='45356' /> > <tag k='addr:street' v='Bottroper Straße' /> > <tag k='amenity' v='fuel' /> > <tag k='brand' v='Aral' /> > <tag k='name' v='Aral' /> > <tag k='operator' v='Aral Q 1 Tankstellenvertrieb GmbH & Co.KG' /> > </node> > <node id='-19' action='modify' visible='true' lat='51.634554' > lon='11.147126'> > <tag k='addr:city' v='Harzgerode' /> > <tag k='addr:country' v='DE' /> > <tag k='addr:housenumber' v='88' /> > <tag k='addr:postcode' v='06493' /> > <tag k='addr:street' v='Augustenstraße' /> > <tag k='amenity' v='fuel' /> > <tag k='brand' v='Aral' /> > <tag k='name' v='Aral' /> > <tag k='operator' v='Aral Q 1 Tankstellenvertrieb GmbH & Co.KG' /> > </node> > <node id='-18' action='modify' visible='true' lat='49.698924' > lon='11.062874'> > <tag k='addr:city' v='Forchheim' /> > <tag k='addr:country' v='DE' /> > <tag k='addr:postcode' v='91301' /> > <tag k='addr:street' v='Am Halben Weg' /> > <tag k='amenity' v='fuel' /> > <tag k='brand' v='Aral' /> > <tag k='name' v='Aral' /> > <tag k='operator' v='Aral Karsten Hennig' /> > </node> > <node id='-16' action='modify' visible='true' lat='49.66992' > lon='9.002631'> > <tag k='addr:city' v='Michelstadt' /> > <tag k='addr:country' v='DE' /> > <tag k='addr:housenumber' v='60' /> > <tag k='addr:postcode' v='64720' /> > <tag k='addr:street' v='Erbacher Straße' /> > <tag k='amenity' v='fuel' /> > <tag k='brand' v='Aral' /> > <tag k='name' v='Aral' /> > <tag k='operator' v='Aral EFA Tankstellenbetriebe und > Mineralölhandel GmbH' /> > </node> > <node id='-13' action='modify' visible='true' lat='47.741719' > lon='8.954761'> > <tag k='addr:city' v='Radolfzell' /> > <tag k='addr:country' v='DE' /> > <tag k='addr:housenumber' v='8' /> > <tag k='addr:postcode' v='78315' /> > <tag k='addr:street' v='Eisenbahnstraße' /> > <tag k='amenity' v='fuel' /> > <tag k='brand' v='Aral' /> > <tag k='name' v='Aral' /> > <tag k='operator' v='Aral Brüder Ley GmbH' /> > </node> > <node id='-12' action='modify' visible='true' lat='48.237397' > lon='9.882374'> > <tag k='addr:city' v='Laupheim' /> > <tag k='addr:country' v='DE' /> > <tag k='addr:housenumber' v='91' /> > <tag k='addr:postcode' v='88471' /> > <tag k='addr:street' v='Ulmer Straße' /> > <tag k='amenity' v='fuel' /> > <tag k='brand' v='Aral' /> > <tag k='name' v='Aral' /> > <tag k='operator' v='Aral Rolf Pohl' /> > </node> > <node id='-11' action='modify' visible='true' lat='51.322091' > lon='6.591331'> > <tag k='addr:city' v='Krefeld' /> > <tag k='addr:country' v='DE' /> > <tag k='addr:housenumber' v='210' /> > <tag k='addr:postcode' v='47805' /> > <tag k='addr:street' v='Untergath' /> > <tag k='amenity' v='fuel' /> > <tag k='brand' v='Aral' /> > <tag k='name' v='Aral' /> > <tag k='operator' v='Aral Hilde Janßen' /> > </node> > <node id='-10' action='modify' visible='true' lat='51.542489' > lon='7.459006'> > <tag k='addr:city' v='Dortmund' /> > <tag k='addr:country' v='DE' /> > <tag k='addr:housenumber' v='79' /> > <tag k='addr:postcode' v='44145' /> > <tag k='addr:street' v='Evinger Straße' /> > <tag k='amenity' v='fuel' /> > <tag k='brand' v='Aral' /> > <tag k='name' v='Aral' /> > <tag k='operator' v='Aral Bavaria Petrol GmbH & Co. KG' /> > </node> > </osm> > > Planned next steps: > > * If agreed: upload of this .osm file to add 8 amenity=fuel objects > * Publish the planned changes of the Aral petrol station tags > * If changes are agreed: upload of the changeset
8 objects? Just hit the upload button, no need to waste more time with discussions. Pavel -- (english) http://www.livejournal.com/~pavelmachek (cesky, pictures) http://atrey.karlin.mff.cuni.cz/~pavel/picture/horses/blog.html _______________________________________________ Imports mailing list Imports@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/imports