Subject: Re: complain to CSE and Down to Earth, New Delhi about your reporter.
> Dear Sunita I do not have any complain about your organisation.Confusion > was created. I complained to your organisation and i waited for fourdays. > But there was no reply. > I have been associated with your organisation from last 8 to 9 years.I > never felt humiliated earlier. Many of your earlier reporters has taken > help from me and proper acknowledgement was given. Inspite of several > letter to your organisation about my complain there was complete silent. > If any reply would have been there from your side or from Anupama I would > have not move forward. I know that it had hurt you also. I am sorry about > that but you keep yourself in my position. I have spend lots of money and > my efforts to collect and analyse the data. You also know that analysing > geochemical data is very costly today.Anupama requested me to send the > information. If she had not mentioned the name of CSE I would have never > send the data or any report. I am sure you will agree with me that name of > the CSE should not be misused. > Earlier today Anupama send me a type of abusing letter. In all my carrier > I have never received such types of humiliating letter. As if I have done > some blunder by helping your researcher. Every value of the parameters > mentioned in the table is given my me to Anupama.Its my researched data > and published in the different journals. I hope you have been misinformed. > Anupama accepts that she has taken the table from my article. She also > says that the table >> never contains the name of any >> particular person. I do not know what does this mean. > Again I say I waited for four days.I have send > you the complained letter last Saturday. > > Ok I also think this matter should be closed. > warm regards > take care > Dr. Nitish Priyadarshi > Geologist > 76,circular road, > Ranchi-834001 > Jharkhand > India > Tel.no. 091-0651-2562895 (R) 2562909 (R) > Mobile: 09835162642 > email: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > [EMAIL PROTECTED] > http://nitishpriyadarshi.blogspot.com > > [EMAIL PROTECTED] > ----- Original Message ----- > From: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > To: "Nitish Priyadarshi" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Cc: "Narayani Ganesh" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Nikhat Aslam" > <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "PhilipNeri deSouza" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; > "ku anupama" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Evan" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "A M > Patwardhan" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Gupta Khemraj" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; > "sunita" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "souparno" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Sent: Saturday, April 19, 2008 3:19 PM > Subject: Re: complain to CSE and Down to Earth, New Delhi about your > reporter. > > >> Dear Dr Priyadarshi >> >> This is regarding the email you sent CSE about your complaint on the use >> of material by Anupama Kumari, a senior journalist from Jharkhand. I >> understand that you have posted your mail and allegations on different >> e-groups and also sent it to a number of people. I would have expected >> that you should have waited for a response to your mail, which was sent >> to us only two days ago. Since the receipt of your mail, my colleague >> Souparno Banerjee has checked the matter with Anumpama Kumari so that we >> could respond to your allegations. >> >> I am forwarding to you the mail you must have already received from >> Anupama clarifying the matter. Please note, firstly, that under no >> circumstances was this material asked for by CSE. Anumpama was doing a >> media fellowship for us, on the subject of rivers. Under the terms of our >> fellowship, the journalist does the work for the newspaper, which agrees >> to publish the material. I therefore fail to understand how you can make >> such strong allegations against CSE, without any foundation. >> >> I am personally extremely saddened to get your mail as I remember our >> interaction in Ranchi, not so very long ago. I do believe that working >> together becomes difficult when our own community makes unfounded >> allegations and without even waiting to get responses, rushes to condemn >> and abuse. Every organisation and individual can make mistakes and I >> would have been more than willing to apologise to you if even >> inadvertently my colleagues had indeed taken material without any >> acknowledgment or had hurt the sentiments of academic researchers. But >> clearly, this is not the case in this matter. >> >> I hope this reply will close the matter and we can all put it behind us. >> >> I expect you to put this response on the different e-groups on which you >> have posted your complaint. This will provide all readers a fair >> opportunity to judge the matter. >> >> With regards >> Sunita >> >> >> >> >> Respected souparno ji, >> >> As per our telecon I am sending you >> the mail. Today I have also sent a >> mail to Nitish ji and I am forwarding the >> same. I am also sending you the >> mailing address of the newspaper >> where the article published. The id is: >> [EMAIL PROTECTED] and the >> contact no. of the editor (Sri Anurag >> Kasshyap >> ji) is 9431942829. >> >> Regards, >> Anupama >> >> >> >> ---------- Forwarded message ---------- >> From: anupama kumari >> <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >> Date: Apr 19, 2008 10:00 AM >> Subject: information about article >> To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] >> >> >> Respected Nitish ji, >> >> I am very much astonished to see >> your attitude. I have a great regard >> for you but seeing your hidden face I am >> really astonished. First of all I would >> like to inform you that you should not >> blame to CSE. Because it has its >> own credibility and is in no way >> responsible for my article which was >> published in the weekly newspapper 7days on >> 19th April, 08. >> >> Secondly, I would like to say >> that I have done a vast research on >> damodar and Swarnrekha rivers and >> have travelled about 50 villages and >> met more than 200 people living in the >> nearby areas and associated with >> Damodar river. They are the officials, the >> activists, the common men and >> others. >> In my article no data is taken from your >> article except the Table and the table >> never contains the name of any >> particular person. All the datas were >> collected by me. If your article >> contains the whole data which I put >> in my article just let me know in which >> article you have written that data & >> where it has been published. If not its my >> kind request that you should not try >> to defame anyone and also hope you >> will behave like a bonevolent writer >> and a gentle man. >> >> Regards, >> Anupama >> >> >> ----- Original Message ----- >> From: "Nitish Priyadarshi" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >> To: [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED], "Evan" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, >> "A M Patwardhan" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Gupta Khemraj" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >> Cc: "Narayani Ganesh" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Nikhat Aslam" >> <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "PhilipNeri deSouza" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, >> "ku anupama" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >> Sent: Wednesday, April 16, 2008 3:31:32 PM (GMT+0530) Asia/Calcutta >> Subject: complain to CSE and Down to Earth, New Delhi about your >> reporter. >>
