Dear Dr. Priyadarshi, Thanks for forwarding the matters. Now I understand very clearly that this matter has nothing to do with the CSE therefore we have responsibility to maintain the credibility of CSE as it has. I also understand that the matter has deeply upset Ms. Sunita Narayan as she has dedicated her whole efforts for the CSE. Anyway now we have nothing than appoligise to the CSE.
But It was really painful for me to read the mail of Anupama Kumari which she has sent to you. She even does not know how to respect a senior person. The irony is that she has accepted of taking table from your paper but at the same time she says that the name was not mentioned in the paper. In this case, how does she know that this table belong to Dr. Nitish Priyadarshi? She must be ask to clarify whole the matters. I would suggest that why dont you directly talk to her? I know you may not be in the possition to talk to her as she has humilated you. But how does she dare to do so? Why she should not be taught a lession for her misconduct? She is not a big (Senior) Journalist. She is just an upcoming one and this is not a good thing for her if she wants to grow in Journalism especially in the state of Jharkhand. Rgds Gladson Dungdung On Sat, 19 Apr 2008 Nitish Priyadarshi wrote : >Subject: Re: complain to CSE and Down to Earth, New Delhi about your >reporter. > > > > Dear Sunita I do not have any complain about your organisation.Confusion > > was created. I complained to your organisation and i waited for fourdays. > > But there was no reply. > > I have been associated with your organisation from last 8 to 9 years.I > > never felt humiliated earlier. Many of your earlier reporters has taken > > help from me and proper acknowledgement was given. Inspite of several > > letter to your organisation about my complain there was complete silent. > > If any reply would have been there from your side or from Anupama I would > > have not move forward. I know that it had hurt you also. I am sorry about > > that but you keep yourself in my position. I have spend lots of money and > > my efforts to collect and analyse the data. You also know that analysing > > geochemical data is very costly today.Anupama requested me to send the > > information. If she had not mentioned the name of CSE I would have never > > send the data or any report. I am sure you will agree with me that name of > > the CSE should not be misused. > > Earlier today Anupama send me a type of abusing letter. In all my carrier > > I have never received such types of humiliating letter. As if I have done > > some blunder by helping your researcher. Every value of the parameters > > mentioned in the table is given my me to Anupama.Its my researched data > > and published in the different journals. I hope you have been misinformed. > > Anupama accepts that she has taken the table from my article. She also > > says that the table > >> never contains the name of any > >> particular person. I do not know what does this mean. > > Again I say I waited for four days.I have send > > you the complained letter last Saturday. > > > > Ok I also think this matter should be closed. > > warm regards > > take care > > Dr. Nitish Priyadarshi > > Geologist > > 76,circular road, > > Ranchi-834001 > > Jharkhand > > India > > Tel.no. 091-0651-2562895 (R) 2562909 (R) > > Mobile: 09835162642 > > email: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > http://nitishpriyadarshi.blogspot.com > > > > [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > ----- Original Message ----- > > From: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > To: "Nitish Priyadarshi" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > Cc: "Narayani Ganesh" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Nikhat Aslam" > > <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "PhilipNeri deSouza" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; > > "ku anupama" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Evan" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "A M > > Patwardhan" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Gupta Khemraj" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; > > "sunita" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "souparno" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > Sent: Saturday, April 19, 2008 3:19 PM > > Subject: Re: complain to CSE and Down to Earth, New Delhi about your > > reporter. > > > > > >> Dear Dr Priyadarshi > >> > >> This is regarding the email you sent CSE about your complaint on the use > >> of material by Anupama Kumari, a senior journalist from Jharkhand. I > >> understand that you have posted your mail and allegations on different > >> e-groups and also sent it to a number of people. I would have expected > >> that you should have waited for a response to your mail, which was sent > >> to us only two days ago. Since the receipt of your mail, my colleague > >> Souparno Banerjee has checked the matter with Anumpama Kumari so that we > >> could respond to your allegations. > >> > >> I am forwarding to you the mail you must have already received from > >> Anupama clarifying the matter. Please note, firstly, that under no > >> circumstances was this material asked for by CSE. Anumpama was doing a > >> media fellowship for us, on the subject of rivers. Under the terms of our > >> fellowship, the journalist does the work for the newspaper, which agrees > >> to publish the material. I therefore fail to understand how you can make > >> such strong allegations against CSE, without any foundation. > >> > >> I am personally extremely saddened to get your mail as I remember our > >> interaction in Ranchi, not so very long ago. I do believe that working > >> together becomes difficult when our own community makes unfounded > >> allegations and without even waiting to get responses, rushes to condemn > >> and abuse. Every organisation and individual can make mistakes and I > >> would have been more than willing to apologise to you if even > >> inadvertently my colleagues had indeed taken material without any > >> acknowledgment or had hurt the sentiments of academic researchers. But > >> clearly, this is not the case in this matter. > >> > >> I hope this reply will close the matter and we can all put it behind us. > >> > >> I expect you to put this response on the different e-groups on which you > >> have posted your complaint. This will provide all readers a fair > >> opportunity to judge the matter. > >> > >> With regards > >> Sunita > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> Respected souparno ji, > >> > >> As per our telecon I am sending you > >> the mail. Today I have also sent a > >> mail to Nitish ji and I am forwarding the > >> same. I am also sending you the > >> mailing address of the newspaper > >> where the article published. The id is: > >> [EMAIL PROTECTED] and the > >> contact no. of the editor (Sri Anurag > >> Kasshyap > >> ji) is 9431942829. > >> > >> Regards, > >> Anupama > >> > >> > >> > >> ---------- Forwarded message ---------- > >> From: anupama kumari > >> <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > >> Date: Apr 19, 2008 10:00 AM > >> Subject: information about article > >> To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > >> > >> > >> Respected Nitish ji, > >> > >> I am very much astonished to see > >> your attitude. I have a great regard > >> for you but seeing your hidden face I am > >> really astonished. First of all I would > >> like to inform you that you should not > >> blame to CSE. Because it has its > >> own credibility and is in no way > >> responsible for my article which was > >> published in the weekly newspapper 7days on > >> 19th April, 08. > >> > >> Secondly, I would like to say > >> that I have done a vast research on > >> damodar and Swarnrekha rivers and > >> have travelled about 50 villages and > >> met more than 200 people living in the > >> nearby areas and associated with > >> Damodar river. They are the officials, the > >> activists, the common men and > >> others. > >> In my article no data is taken from your > >> article except the Table and the table > >> never contains the name of any > >> particular person. All the datas were > >> collected by me. If your article > >> contains the whole data which I put > >> in my article just let me know in which > >> article you have written that data & > >> where it has been published. If not its my > >> kind request that you should not try > >> to defame anyone and also hope you > >> will behave like a bonevolent writer > >> and a gentle man. > >> > >> Regards, > >> Anupama > >> > >> > >> ----- Original Message ----- > >> From: "Nitish Priyadarshi" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > >> To: [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED], "Evan" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, > >> "A M Patwardhan" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Gupta Khemraj" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > >> Cc: "Narayani Ganesh" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Nikhat Aslam" > >> <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "PhilipNeri deSouza" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, > >> "ku anupama" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > >> Sent: Wednesday, April 16, 2008 3:31:32 PM (GMT+0530) Asia/Calcutta > >> Subject: complain to CSE and Down to Earth, New Delhi about your > >> reporter. > >> Gladson Dungdung Khorha Toli, Mission Colony, Kokar, Ranchi - 834001
