On 01/12/2015 11:50, Stephen Colebourne wrote:
:
I personally am far from convinced that the compatibility of JDK 9
with 8 is going to be good enough. Especially as it seems to me that
all libraries that use reflection are likely to be broken with 9,
something that will significantly hamper adoption.
This seems a bit pessimistic. One thing that would be helpful is to get
more help testing of these libraries with the EA builds. If there are
libraries and applications on the class path today that are using core
reflection then they should continue to work as they do in JDK 8. The
only issue starting out should be where core reflection is being used to
get at JDK internal types, in which case a command-line option might be
needed to keep those deployments working.
If your comment is more about the challenge that some frameworks will
have with strong encapsulation then it's a fair concern. As things
currently stand then there isn't a mechanism (aside from the command
line) to give specific frameworks the power to break encapsulation and
get at the internals of other modules. So definitely some TBD here,
maybe on the framework side too because modules might provide an
opportunity to revisit a few things.
-Alan
