Billy wrote:

>You're right, Bob. Joni picked "Captain For >Dark Mornings" (from Nyro's
NYT'berry) >rather than "Captain St. Lucifer."

Oops!  Thanks for the clarification - I love both those "Captains."

> The former, along with "Tom Cat >Goodby" (Laura's spelling) and the title
> track remain my absolute favorites from that >masterpiece of an album.

Wow, in all my years I have never met any other Laura fan who also had Tom
Cat as their favorite!  It is spectacular.

>Searing  brilliance from start to finish.
> However, I disagree (as a longtime Nyro->ut) that "NYT" & "Xmas" sound
like
> they could have come from the same record. >they sound nothing alike to
me.

I've always equated "Xmas" in some ways to Joni's "Hejira" - both are so
seamless and represent albums entirely filled with flawless lyrics.

>Kakki--I agree that Joni's "For The Roses" is >on a par (and perhaps a bit
similar) with >"NYT." As you stated,  both are very deep-->and endlessly
rewarding.

After listening to it again last night I also started thinking that NYT was
similar to Joni's DJRD album in the sense that both have moments of soaring
off the edge into wild and sometimes cryptic, realms.

I think Laura and Joni are absolutely equal in their genius but neither can
be compared in style to the other and that is wonderful.

Kakki

NPIMH:  "I lost my eyes in east wind skies, here where I cried, where I've
tried, where God and the tendaberry rise, where quakers and revolutionaries
join for life, for precious years, join for life, through silver tears, New
York tendaberry"

Reply via email to