Have you ever seen her do 'Old Man River?'  I have a video
> given to me by my neice and she sings that one on it.  Never have I seen
> such a performance.  And this wasn't a studio but a live audience
> performance.  Not a missed note.  Don't know the particular venue.

This was probably from 'The Judy Garland Show', her ill-fated variety show
that CBS gave the kiss of death by airing it opposite 'Bonanza' on Sunday
nights.  She also did the most amazing rendition of 'The Battle Hymn of the
Republic' after John F. Kennedy was assassinated.  She wanted to dedicate it
to him but the brass at the network wouldn't let her.  Kennedy used to call
Judy when he was president and ask her to sing 'Over the Rainbow' to him
over the phone.  'The Battle Hymn of the Republic' has to be heard (or
better still, seen and heard) to be believed.  The woman looks and sounds
like she's going to explode - it is so passionate, powerful and intense.

'The Man That Got Away' would have made my list if I'd continued with it.
The Carnegie Hall rendition is magnificent but the version that's in 'A Star
Is Born' is absolutely amazing as well.  Judy was one of a kind and there
will never be another like her.

Mark E in Seattle

Reply via email to