https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=402660

--- Comment #24 from Stuart K. Smith <stuartksm...@gmail.com> ---
There seems to be a lot of rambling on this bug report about loosely related
topics. My issue is that a USB device should not have to be unplugged and
re-inserted by design. That is a very poor working practice. You should be able
to choose or default to Unmount rather than Eject (aka "Safely Remove") devices
that do not require ejection.

Is there no way for the programming of the Device Notifier to detect if a
plugged in device is a spinning hard drive vs. a USB thumb drive? BTW, my WD
USB spinning hard drive does not need to be "parked" to be removed.

This effectively make Notifier mostly useless for USB thumb drives. If I have
to go to the command line so I don't have to reach behind my monitor or PC case
to unplug and reinsert my USB drive, then why have the GUI Notifier?

At a minimum, "Unmount" should be in the options available and at best be the
default choice when clicking the up arrow in Notifier. I'd bet that there are
oodles more thumb drives being used than portable hard drives. Let the lesser
sized user group have the extra "Fully Eject" option available in the action
list but make Unmount the option. Seems way more logical to me.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are watching all bug changes.

Reply via email to