Olivier Blin <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > "Luiz Fernando N. Capitulino" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > >> - Prevent fixed button event to reach userspace on S3 resume > > Why put that in a kernel update for a stable release? > Users are meant to use pmsuspend from the suspend-scripts package, > which already handles that.
... which is not the case. Not all users are using pmsuspend (and iirc also not all of our tools too). I can even remember someoine pointing me a thread about that on the club forums. > > Furthermore, it will break the power button event after a resume done > with suspend-scripts, since /etc/acpi/actions/poweroff.sh has to be > run on the event you just removed (to remove a lock file). So that means, there are cases where the suspend scripts were broken :( On some boxes, when the acpi resume of some devices is more or less broken (either on bios or on driver side), you may not get the power button event.... Depending on the device, the user may not detect that the device failed to resume.
