Steve & Jeff are thinking positive, my cynical comment on electric 'turbos' 
failed to convey my approval of conventional exhaust turbos. My current plan 
is to installa l a normally aspirated EA81 which I have, as a possible 
forerunner to a factory turbo fuel injected EA81(comp ratio,pistons, valves 
etc should be ok, its the cooling side to take care of - space & weight 
would be marginal on a KR though?). with a new plane in the air who needs 
possible extra problems to sort out first few hours up? The other concern is 
my caution regarding anythying computer/electronic going wrong at even 
1000'.  We have a lot of hills & mountains here.But I still hanker for a 
corvair core engine to use - another plea to anyone who can help get one 
down to NewZealand - corvairs are rarer than rockin horse turds downunder!
----- Original Message ----- 
From: "Jeff York" <[email protected]>
To: "KRnet" <[email protected]>
Sent: Tuesday, January 04, 2011 6:20 AM
Subject: Re: KR> To Turbo or not to Turbo that is the Question


I, as well as Steve (as he stated)  would enjoy hearing more about the 
positives
on turbo charging too.

That said, I want to say that I did not want to come off sounding negative, 
I
just wanted to point out my concerns about turbo charging from my 
experience's
in high performance turbo charging. There are so many benefits to turbo 
charging

an engine from performance in power and fuel economy. Yes I said fuel 
economy
and what I meant by that was you can run a normally smaller displacement 
engine
to gain economy while getting the benefits of additional power by force 
feeding
air/fuel via the turbo. My problem was I never could keep my foot out of it 
to
really see the fuel economies but they are there.

Also, my experience was performance related and not of the altitude 
normalizing
that would be associated with aircraft turbo applications. However, some of 
the
same issues apply. I pointed out, and Steve and others pointed them out as 
well.



The main concerns I would have are oil and engine temps due to the very high
temps a turbo can achieve. As I recall 1600 degrees F. As Steve pointed out, 
I
would never consider a turbo without a intercooler. An intercooler is used 
to
cool

the turbo charged air fuel after it goes through the turbo and before it 
enters
the combustion chamber. Do not mistake the idea that an intercooler is for
cooling the turbo charger. Its not. That will be the job of your over sized 
oil
cooler.



When the engine in a turbo charged motor is shut down, that 1600 degree 
turbo
(which is oil cooled) will act as a furnace to cook the remaining oil in the
turbo. This will effectively coke the oil. This is why normal shut down of a
turbo charged motor is not recommended. Its why turbo timers are used to
circulate that oil after engine shut down.

I know the Dragonfly guys and Tri Q guys did a lot of turbo charging of the
Subaru motors and some of the Corvair guys had been looking into it or have 
done

it. But I believe weight and engine life issues may have slowed down or 
halted
the use and development of those turbo applications. One more thing. It was 
my
understanding when I did turbos on performance applications that you did not
just slap a turbo on any engine. Don't put ten pounds of boost on a 9 to 1 
or 10

to 1 compression motor and expect it to hold together very long. You will
effectively have a
19 or 20 to 1 compression motor. These are diesels. That kind of compression
will blow up
 a motor. Also, make sure you have the right exhaust valves to handle a 
turbo or
you will be burning them

up. Not fun pulling off to the side of the road at 10,000 feet when you eat 
a
valve cook a piston or blow a head gasket.

It was a lot of fun doing turbo apps in automotive applications. Computer
controlled air fuel metering, precise BOV/ Waste gate control, air/fuel 
mixture
control and other systems

allowed reliable power gains. I am not sure I have seen anything better than 
old

unreliable mechanical systems available to do this on a VW motor. But what 
the
William Winns and MJ's and ML's are doing with the systems they have 
available
on Corvair motors would to me seem to be the better platform in which to 
start a

turbo project.

I love my GPAS VW and all that Steve Bennett has done. But the fastest way 
for
me to mess up all that reliability is to slap a turbo on my VW motor without
finding out if and how it can be done reliably.


OK, I have ranted enough. I too want to hear from those that have done it so 
as
to get the positive and learn how. Thats what this is all about.

Sorry for running on but, I hope I was informative in some way as to the how
what to look out for and what not to do. I would love to get 70, 80 or more
horsepower out of my VW motor and if I could add a turbo to it and get 
reliable
life out of it, I would do it. But, in my opinion,  it might make more sense 
to
look at a Corvair that can get 100 hp or one of these 23xx VW motors.

But, lets hear from the ones who know how and have, instead of us (me) who 
know
how not to.

By the way, I worked on some turbo spam cans that came into the aviation 
shop I
used to work in. But they were very rare. I have to wonder why they were so
rare.

Jeff York
KR-2 N839BG
Lexington/ Georgetown, Kentucky



----- Original Message ----
From: "Teate, Stephen" <[email protected]>
To: KRnet <[email protected]>
Sent: Mon, January 3, 2011 10:22:28 AM
Subject: RE: KR> To Turbo or not to Turbo that is the Question


"I've already heard some of the negatives from others, but does anyone have 
a
list of positives?"

Both Jeff Scott and Jeff York have responded to this and made excellent 
comments
to be considered. I admit I am biased to the positive side of turbo's so I 
will
add my opinion.




_______________________________________
Search the KRnet Archives at http://www.maddyhome.com/krsrch/index.jsp
to UNsubscribe from KRnet, send a message to [email protected]
please see other KRnet info at http://www.krnet.org/info.html


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



No virus found in this incoming message.
Checked by AVG - www.avg.com
Version: 8.5.449 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/3356 - Release Date: 01/03/11 
07:34:00

Reply via email to