On the subject of designing and writing instructions for working the piece:
I think there are two classes of designs -- those for beginners or near
beginners, and those for advanced lacemakers.  A design which contains only
simple techniques will appeal to beginners, who need very full instructions.
If a design for free/part lace includes raised work, or anything
non-typical, then I think you only need specify the size thread you used and
the maximum number of bobbins for each part.  And perhaps an indication of
working order.  Also any really unusual techniques might have a diagram.

I don't think one should expect a beginner to work a Flanders pattern or a
piece with raised work.  An experienced lacemaker doesn't need full
instructions, but just hints for the hard parts.  I don't think it is
reasonable for a beginner to expect to learn basic bobbin lace techniques
from a pattern published in the bulletin.  It seems to me that these
contests serve to inspire lacemakers to add to the wealth of designs that
all lacemakers can draw from.  They are contemporary additions to the
tradition.  I think it reasonable to assume that it is experienced
lacemakers who will be interested in the patterns.  Beginners should be
working through a book aimed at beginners, so that she or he can master the
basic set of techniques that all lacemakers should learn.  My personal view
is that a beginner shouldn't expect to learn bobbin lace by tackling
difficult innovative patterns.  Anyway, that is my not-particularly-humble
opinion.

Those of you who are contributing to the contest are doing us all a favor by
creating new designs.  Don't demand of yourself that you write a book of all
bobbin lace technique to accompany your pattern.
Lorelei
-
To unsubscribe send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] containing the line:
unsubscribe lace [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to