In message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Lorelei Halley
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes
> I don't think it is
>reasonable for a beginner to expect to learn basic bobbin lace techniques
>from a pattern published in the bulletin.  

>  Beginners should be
>working through a book aimed at beginners, so that she or he can master the
>basic set of techniques that all lacemakers should learn.  

I hope I am reading this wrong.  As a teacher, I introduce my students
to the magazines I have access to - with the hope that they will
subscribe/join the organisation - and likewise, when demonstrating
(usually for The Lace Guild) hope to gain new members.  How many times I
have heard a lacemaker say "but I'm only a beginner.." as if the
magazines were *only* for the experienced, and that membership of
whatever guild or society is far beyond their reach.  This is, and
should be, far from the truth - though if the only patterns published
are for experienced lacemakers, because of the attitude that beginners
should be working through books it makes me wonder!  Books which often
too expensive for beginners' budgets will be available to them through
the libraries of the various guilds and organisations, and this is one
reason in favour of their joining - but if the magazine, which is what
they see as "what they get in return for their subscription" is way
above their standard, they are put off joining.

I do not subscribe to IOLI, but I do hope that as with Lace, (The Lace
Guild's magazine), the editor has a brief to include some patterns
suitable for beginners as well as the more advanced - simple patterns
are quite often more effective than the difficult, complicated ones -
and help to encourage new members at the stage in their lacemaking that
they need most support.  Maybe they are not learning new techniques from
the magazine, but using it to complement a book and give further
practice pieces - but there have been a number of people who have
successfully learnt new techniques in this way (Jean Leader's series on
Bucks Point, published in Lace before the book was compiled, is a very
solid example).  Not everyone has access to a teacher, or another live
lacemaker, and in these cases a magazine can be a lifeline.

One of the reasons why I like the Canadian Lacemaker Gazette is that it
is one of the few that doesn't make a beginner run a mile!

-- 
Jane Partridge
-
To unsubscribe send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] containing the line:
unsubscribe lace [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to