On Sep 20, 2011, at 11:02 AM, Ian Batten wrote:

> On 20 Sep 2011, at 1036, Rob Seaman wrote:
> 
>> Ask yourself if your position is really that clocks could tick at any 
>> randomly chosen rate picked out of a hat?
> 
> No-one's saying that.  If you're asking the question "could civil clocks tick 
> at any randomly chosen rate that is within 1ppm of what astronomers say it 
> should be" then the answer is "yes".

Ok.  So the assertion is that 1 ppm is acceptable.  Systematic errors are 
different than random errors (however distributed), but let's ignore that not 
so minor distinction.

Let's see…1 ppm is 0.0864 seconds per day.  That is a leap second (or 
equivalent drift) every 11.57 days.  A leap hour (presuming such is 
implementable) every 114 years.  Is this acceptable?  Says who?  What process 
should be followed?  Who should be consulted?  If the answer is easy - then 
it's easy to write it down.

So let's say consensus is reached on 1 ppm, or maybe 10 ppm or 0.1 ppm.  What 
is this tolerance measured against?  Right!  Time-of-day = mean solar time.  
What is "LOD" in all those plots?  Requirements describe the problem space.  
Mean solar time is a requirement.  1 ppm would be a specification against a 
proposed solution suitable for evaluation by a trade-off, risks, costs, 
schedule, sensitivity analyses, etc.

Glad to see consensus that clocks cannot actually tick at any old rate.  What 
can we reach consensus on next?  What process most efficiently promotes 
consensus?

Rob

_______________________________________________
LEAPSECS mailing list
[email protected]
http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/leapsecs

Reply via email to