On 20 September 2011 13:51, Daniel R. Tobias <[email protected]> wrote: >> You wouldn't be leaping UTC, you'd be leaping civil time. We're >> used to that. > Though we're not used to any local civil times being over 24 hours > removed from UTC, which would happen eventually after a few millennia > of UTC being uncoupled from solar time.
Yes, the tzdata offset "solution" has odd consequences. Many people know and use the +01:00 notation for Paris or -05:00 notation for New York. Having those start changing dramatically isn't appealing to me... +37:00 for Paris anyone? I'd also note that plenty of code/standards assumes that the offset is limited in range, such as -14:00 to +14:00. There is a cost to change right there. Plus, there is another more subtle down side. By using tzdata for this, it places the control in the hands of politicians. Whereas, up until now, the core definition of civil time (GMT/UTC) has essentially been controlled by scientists and technologists (sure you might argue on some finer details in that claim, but in broad brush I'd argue it is very true). Personally, I think it would be very unwise to give up control to politician of the core clock that is used by the world's population (yes, "UTC" would still be driven by science, but it would be irrelevant to real people, in the same way that TAI is today). Saying that people just care about the time on the news or their wall isn't enough - they do care about offsets too, and decoupling those from anything meaningful is just asking for trouble. Stephen _______________________________________________ LEAPSECS mailing list [email protected] http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/leapsecs
