On Sep 20, 2011, at 10:33 AM, Gerard Ashton wrote:
> So we have no choice but to suppose that the letter of the 
> law/rule/regulation/standard is important, else why bother to establish the 
> law/rule/regulation/standard in the first place.

We do have a choice.  The letter of the law/regulation is sometimes followed 
very carefully.  Other times it is a codification of what seemed to be a 
reasonable approximation.

With hunting, day hunting is different than night hunting.  Night hunting is 
generally frowned upon because it makes it too easy to take the animals, too 
hard for game wardens to enforce the rules and too easy to shoot your fellow 
man thinking he was a 40-point buck.  While dawn/dusk has more wiggle room in 
it than sunrise/sunset would on the planes, in the mountains, they are easier 
to police.

Both are approximations of the "well, you should only hunt when it is light 
enough" and nobody carries around tables of times and everybody generally 
agrees when it is dusk or dawn.  They could have written the rules to say "You 
can only hunt when the ambient light from the sun is more than so many 
candelas" which makes any time tinkering irrelevant.  But such a technical 
refinement of the rules may lead to other unintended consequences, or it may 
have no practical effect at all.  It is hard to say.

Warner


_______________________________________________
LEAPSECS mailing list
[email protected]
http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/leapsecs

Reply via email to