List censors please stop here. I refer you to your delete key. I'll put some stuff about musical piss ups in mud at the end so you could go straight there of course. Delete, scroll down, or read. It's a free choice. ----- Original Message ----- > Clarification was sought, none was forthcoming most of the time. There > was probably a reason behind the inability to spell out what the issue > was, but we weren't even told that.
Betraying confidences is far from being the only consideration. There are many other considerations. I'll do my best to provide some insight but it is not a simple matter. Firstly when talking about Scratchingshed you must bear in mind the Spartacus defence. Nobody is now in a position to speak for the Scratchingshed group and this is now merely history, as is SLU. Because of my involvement with various groups and initiatives for a few years past I can make some comments though. I think that the issues were always quite clear but what was asked for was black and white very specific answers. Frequently to give such answers would have been unwise. Sometimes it simply was not black and white. Sometimes very specific answers were given only to be followed by demands for proof. Again that was very obviously not always possible. There is of course the alternative of saying nothing but that brings its own complaints of elitism, cliques, insiders and outsiders and the deliberate generation of an us and them argument simply to win a few points and not to further the discussion. This is not aimed specifically at yourself, by the way. Also if you do nothing with important information then people stop giving that information. Consider for a minute the transfer of the ground to a BVI company which took place shortly after the Bates take-over. At what point should that have been made public and why ? What would the consequences have been ? What would have been acheived ? What should fans do for the greatest benefit to the team ? This is only one in a long line of issues. Consider the knowledge that despite what Krasner wanted the first Kransortium fans forum to believe it was KNOWN that the bondholders had NOT been dealt with so that they were no longer an issue, and that there were at the very least contingent liabilities which had implications for league status. Remembering that this was supposedly the best news that Leeds fans had had for some considerable time (the first "rescue" of the club), again - At what point should that have been made public and why ? What would the consequences have been ? What would have been acheived ? What should fans do for the greatest benefit to the team ? Remember that Bill Gerrard told the media at the time that the takeover was massively underfunded and that he saw major problems and consider the fans reaction to being told this TOTALLY CORRECT information. The REALITY does not actually match the pictures that you are painting. I can confirm that sometimes items were put onto this list (or sometimes on Waccoe or elsewhere) that were only intended to be understood by very specific targets. This is much in the same way that front page small adds were used in The Times in previous eras. Although most readers would be left scratching their heads (or sheds) the intended targets immediately got the point. This gave them the opportunity to take action in the face of an implied (and ONLY implied) threat that the knowledge was out there and might be used by others if action was not taken by themselves. > This 'debate' is slightly different. I cant see any reason why you > yourself > didn't spell out, as you did a couple of days ago, why you have a problem > with Bates/CVA/buyback. You seem to be doing so now without any problem. You appear to NOW understand and accept the reasons for some of the reporting of the past but I have to ask if YOU have learned anything by that ? Has your understanding and acceptance changed your approach to this in any way or is it just the same again ? A few months ago I became chairman of the Trust. The Trust has to work with whoever owns and runs the football club. Personal preferences are not relevant. Personal opinion is personal. What I am pointing out, if anything, about the Bates buyback is mostly factual about how it was done and the tactics and procedures involved. The effect of such tactics is NOT a fact and it would be irrisponsible to do anything other than allowing people to make their own minds up. It is clear that there are very many who are unwilling to reach any conclusions for themselves but that is not my responsibility. I don't have any problem with informing those who were not actually there or those who may not understand what took place. It would be silly for the Trust to ignore the fact that there may be consequences for the club arising from the methods and tactics used. Consider for example the strange lack of reporting or information about the last FL meeting in the Algarve. Would it be reasonable to wonder if the club might be affected in some way by the attitudes of the variious chairmen who were at that meeting ? Mr Bates might be able to get away with poking his fingers into various eyes but that does not prevent a knee-jerk reaction, nor does it prevent a possible desire for revenge tasted cold. I only have one source of information and that is admittedly only second hand but it is from a club chairman who was there. Very little has been said other than that there were considerable land widespread levels of hostility. Quite what they made of Leeds United voting to change the ten point rule has also not been reported. I can't tell you the name of the Chairman nor can I prove what I have just said. You have to consider the balance of probabilities for yourself. Should I simply say nothing or should I warn fellow fans that this may not be over and that there may still be consequences for the club ? Should I be discussing the possibilities with people in the media who have their own contacts and sources of information. If this leads us to think that there may be "downside" problems then should the Trust attempt the difficult task of deflecting the consequences away from anything that would affect the "fans" and onto more deserving recipients ? Most likely it will all come to nothing but that is no reason to ignore it. > For example, if you had said "Willis has asked the house to investigate > the > buyback, I think this is a good thing because Bates has taken the piss, > used > underhand tactics etc and I am worried because his offer had no provision > for team strengthening, the club needs investment desperately and I cannot > see anyone wanting to invest whilst Bates is in charge. I also do not > think > this will affect materially the team on the pitch, indeed if we get a new > owner they will hopefully want rid of Wise because I think he is a useless > little twerp". I think you are advising me that the Trust should follow the example set when an official statement said something on the lines of not having laughed so much since Ma caught her tit in the mangle. I don't agree that this would be a good course of action to take. Sadly the situation is not as black and white nor as simple as you would like it to be. We ARE as a club in a situation which could very definitely materially affect the team on the pitch and we have been put into that situation by the former management of the club and not by any questions in the house. Whether I like this position is again not relevant. Whether I think it is good or bad is not relevant. We are in it no matter what I want and that is what has to be dealt with. I do not control the mood or actions of HMRC but I was aware of their hardline position on football CVAs and the reasons behind it. I could try to consider what the consequences of that might be should Mr Bates and Mr Taylor take the club into administration. THEY made their own judgement and maybe they have judged it to a fine line and all will be well. Maybe their previous experiences of similar moves have lead them to underestimate the level of opposition. I don't know but I can very definitely see the possibilities. Before the administration I publicly expressed my concerns that the actions that the management were about to take would run the very real risk that the football club could be left as piggy-in-the-middle and that there could be severe consequences on the pitch. That chain of events WAS put into action and my concerns have not changed. You appear to have woken up to the possibilities only when an MP asked questions in the house. This particular train could be seen coming long before that point and the MP is NOT the cause. I also think that I need to remind everyone that I DID NOT write any of what you are suggesting that I should have written. I simply do not agree with your argument or with the statements that you think that I should have made, and putting them in quotation marks is totally out of order. > THEN I (and others) would have known where you were coming from and quite > possibly 'debated' on the inward investment possibility or Wise's ability > to > get us up. I would then have seen that you didn't really consider Wise's > preparations as important, and therefore any issue of potential disruption > as less important than those of us who thinks he could do a good job this > season. You wouldn't have seen the investigation on Bates as a threat to > the football team in the same was as I do (as I see Wise as important this > season), and therefore I would not necessarily have thought 'there must be > more to it'. Of course disruption is important but not wanting it to happen is not going to do anything to stop it happeneing. Ranting against an MP who has asked very properly questions that need answering, but which will probably not get answered, is also not going to help. You ignore the fact that the people who SHOULD be most concerned about disruption to the team i.e. Bates and his backers, do nothing to prevent it. THEY are the ones who could answer the questions and prevent any disruption but they do not. That is their choice and any subsequent disruption to the team which arises as a result of their making that choice is squarely THEIR responsibility. Don't shoot the messenger because that won't help either. Oh, and Glasto - No I don't have a ticket but I'll raise a glass or two with you to celebrate.. _______________________________________________ the Leeds List is an unmoderated mailing list and the list administrators accept no liability for the personal views and opinions of contributors. Leedslist mailing list [email protected] http://list.zetnet.co.uk/mailman/listinfo/leedslist Join The Leeds United Supporters Trust at www.lufctrust.org

