>> new contributions with (I'm sorry but thats the truth) bad quality >> over proven ones, that have been existing since 2008 at least, have >> been included into lilypond without questioning its purpose > > (1) Take the specialist's proposal at face value, beyond obvious and > immediate problems > > As you say, "one developer decided to contribute his ideas and > nobody questioned that in the code review." Perhaps because nobody > else involved knew what questions to ask?
Exactly. We are *not* experts for music from Arabia/Turkey/Iran. We take what we get. It was our mistake then to not asking you or other guys for for an expert opinion – this time I've directly contacted Hassan for comments on your MR (hopefully his e-mail address is still valid). > I commend you for submitting a merge request to improve LilyPond's > quality for Arabic music as you see it needs. Yep. It's not too late to fix errors. Werner