On 19 May 1999 Paul Winkler replied to my post:

>> Would the entire production, be it a commercial or movie,
>> need to be copylefted for the material to be used?
>
> I would think the answer is yes. If a film includes your song, it
> would fall under this part of the GPL:
> [GPL section 0]
> This applies even if there's only thirty seconds of your song,
> or a modified version of it, in a 90-minute film.

How do you interpret the last three paragraphs of section 2 in
this context?  Doesn't this lend to a legal paradox in which the
ninety minute film may be distributed in two forms, copylefted
and copyrighted, identical but for including and not including the
thirty seconds of copylefted music?  "The whole of this film is
GPL, except for the 99.8% of it which is copyrighted."  *_*

Not trying to be polemical, just uncertain of the implications.

Reply via email to