On 04/03/2013 09:40, Jeff Wheeler wrote:
> On Mon, Mar 4, 2013 at 6:22 AM, Arturo Servin <[email protected]> wrote:
>> Possibly, but, would it be very different than when RIRs started
>> allocating IPv6?
>
> It was free to members who already had IPv4. That is an important
> distinction.
Nop, at least in the one that I know it was free as the air.
Not sure about the others.
>
> If the "LISP Experiment" only succeeds in issuing EID blocks to
> organizations that already have their own IP blocks and are already
> announcing to the DFZ, then IMO, it will not have been very
> successful.
>
> Why do you suppose I mention godaddy.com in my post? If you want a
> domain name, you can buy one. That's probably not a good way to issue
> IP addresses. On the other hand, if you want a "green browser-bar SSL
> certificate" they have additional identity and authority verification
> hoops for you to jump through. These steps are quite streamlined and
> are performed efficiently by SSL certificate authorities.
>
> My ideal world would allow someone to go get a "very small" block with
> about the same hoops as a $10/year dot-com registration, hopefully at
> a similar cost, and including a mapping service for xTRs to be able to
> find your EID-to-RLOC mapping. The MS relationship may be a tool for
> reduction of abusive registrations that will invariably happen if the
> bar to getting EID space is set very low.
>
> A larger organization might jump through the extra steps and cost
> required to get the green SSL certificate. Then they can have more
> address space, choose their own MS (maybe themself), and gain the
> capability to sub-divide their allocation.
>
> LISP is a pet project. Personally, it makes me want to scream every
> time someone talks to me about how great LISP is, or will be in the
> future. If you folks want it to grow out of the pet project stage
> anytime soon, then you should stop treating it like a pet project and
> start thinking about how to make it scale up effectively -- not just
> in technical terms (like negative map cache entries, which are a
> disaster) but also in business terms, like how do you get an EID block
> so you can actually take advantage of this new technology.
>
> RIRs are not effective organizations to be handing out EIDs to the new
> kind of users that LISP is supposed to empower. You need godaddy-like
> companies to want to do this. You might as well inch further away
> from "pet project" by allowing one or more for-profit businesses to
> gain experience allocating EIDs, and for the community to be able to
> decide if it is a good or bad idea.
>
I though that LISPs users would be ISPs.
And honestly, I do not how a business would have a profit allocating
EIDs.
Regards,
as
_______________________________________________
lisp mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/lisp