On Mon, Mar 4, 2013 at 2:25 PM, Dino Farinacci <[email protected]> wrote: > We are just asking for a well-known prefix.
I think you stand a better chance of actually receiving that prefix if you have a realistic plan for delegating it to participants in your experiment. This is especially true if the system proposed looks more like what a realistic, Internet-scale deployment of LISP might be in the future. The plan I've suggested is realistic and is what would be needed for LISP to succeed in its future goals. You should be cheering it on. Instead you are making very foolish arguments against it, like "we don't want fragmentation because ... cloud ..." That fragmentation actually benefits your project in numerous ways which I have outlined in this thread. If you want people to be able to raise money to start businesses based on promises of LISP, you have a lot more chance of that being successful, too, if someone can actually get an EID block without learning how to deal with an RIR. I suspect most people on this list haven't ever worked with the RIRs. I do on a routine basis for dozens of clients. They make life hugely difficult sometimes, and other times they just go "okay here are your numbers!" for no outwardly-evident reason. Businesses shouldn't have to pay people like me to help them navigate the process, but unfortunately, they do. You need to address that if LISP is going to deliver on its promises. There is NEVER going to be a better time to work toward that than right now. Right now, you are trying to get the EID block. Right now, you can decide that maybe it's valuable to try to get private, competing businesses to efficiently and cost-effectively register IPs in such a way that ordinary people can afford and accomplish it. If you lose that opportunity you may not find it again later, and some of LISP's promise may never be fulfilled. Again, you should be my idea's cheerleader. I will think of a good mascot for when you realize I'm right and decide to go shopping for a giant animal costume. -- Jeff S Wheeler <[email protected]> Sr Network Operator / Innovative Network Concepts _______________________________________________ lisp mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/lisp
