At 06:33 PM 2/16/00 -0500, Gerald Oskoboiny wrote:
>If you do this, please make sure the final step is done with an
>HTTP POST, not a GET as I've seen various sites do lately.
>
>GETting a URL shouldn't have side effects, so if you implement it
>as described above, the page returned by the first URL should
>display a form with a button that can be POSTed to perform the
>actual act of joining or leaving the list.
>
>An alternative is to include a small form in the email message so
>the user can POST it directly with a single click.

I can't possibly disagree with you more.  A URL with some operands should
be expected to do something.  If you mark it, "click here to confirm", then
they click here to confirm.  Why make a user who can barely do one thing do
two things? re we totally addiced to "Are you Sure?" boxes for everything?
We are not writing mail for a browser here.  I send my confirm URL's,
tokens and all, as regular URLs, which default to get whe clicked on.  If
you click on a URL with a bunch of operands, why would you expect it not to
do something?
--
"If Wild Bill Hickock were born in the Internet Age,
he'd probably flame people real bad on-line." 
 --- TLC hyping an episode of "Gunfighters of the West"
Nick Simicich - [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to