On Wed, Mar 10, 1999 at 01:11:21PM -0500, Jay Fenello wrote:
> At 3/10/99, 11:14 AM, Martin B. Schwimmer wrote:
> >>> What qualifies as a domain name holder?
> >>>   -  jay.per.to?
> >>>   -  johnson.com?
> >>>   -  bob.aol.com?
> >>>   -  tom.co.au?
> >>
> >
> >Do you mean [EMAIL PROTECTED]?  does aol allot third level domains?
> 
> 
> I'm not sure, but according to the following posting,
> AOL has over 1,600,000 third level domains in use!

That's an absolutely meaningless statistic for our purposes.  The 
domains that aol has are domains like this (pulled from a bit of my 
server logs):


166-27-102.ipt.aol.com 
167-108-63.ipt.aol.com 
167-130-27.ipt.aol.com 
167-169-71.ipt.aol.com 
171-132-118.ipt.aol.com 
171-32-150.ipt.aol.com 
171-89-189.ipt.aol.com 
174-75-96.ipt.aol.com 
174-8-155.ipt.aol.com 
203-189-45.ipt.aol.com 
204-20-108.ipt.aol.com 
204-239-81.ipt.aol.com 
207-58-104.ipt.aol.com 
cache-da01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-da02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-da03.proxy.aol.com 
cache-da04.proxy.aol.com 
cache-da05.proxy.aol.com 
cache-da06.proxy.aol.com 
cache-da07.proxy.aol.com 
cache-da08.proxy.aol.com 
cache-da09.proxy.aol.com 
cache-da10.proxy.aol.com 
cache-da11.proxy.aol.com 
cache-da12.proxy.aol.com 
cache-da13.proxy.aol.com 
cache-db01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-db02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-db03.proxy.aol.com 
cache-db04.proxy.aol.com 
cache-db05.proxy.aol.com 
cache-db06.proxy.aol.com 
cache-db07.proxy.aol.com 
cache-db08.proxy.aol.com 
cache-db09.proxy.aol.com 
cache-db10.proxy.aol.com 
cache-db11.proxy.aol.com 
cache-db12.proxy.aol.com 
cache-db13.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dc01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dc02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dc03.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dc04.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dc05.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dc06.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dc07.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dc08.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dc09.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dc10.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dc11.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dc12.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dc13.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dd01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dd02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dd03.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dd04.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dd05.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dd06.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dd07.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dd08.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dd09.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dd10.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dd11.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dd12.proxy.aol.com 
cache-dd13.proxy.aol.com 
cache-ra01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-ra02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-ra03.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rb01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rb02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rb03.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rc01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rc02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rc03.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rd01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rd02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rd03.proxy.aol.com 
cache-re01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-re02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-re03.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rf01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rf02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rf03.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rg01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rg02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rg03.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rh01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rh02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rh03.proxy.aol.com 
cache-ri01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-ri02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-ri03.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rj01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rj02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rj03.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rk01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rk02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rk03.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rl01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rl02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rl03.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rm01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rm02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rm03.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rn01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rn02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-rn03.proxy.aol.com 
cache-ro01.proxy.aol.com 
cache-ro02.proxy.aol.com 
cache-ro03.proxy.aol.com 
spider-ta054.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tf053.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tf084.proxy.aol.com 
spider-th082.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tj031.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tj041.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tk052.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tl013.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tm024.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tm064.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tn012.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tn023.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tn074.proxy.aol.com 
spider-to014.proxy.aol.com 
spider-to041.proxy.aol.com 
spider-to084.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tp023.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tp041.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tq011.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tq022.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tq041.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tq051.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tq073.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tr021.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tr024.proxy.aol.com 
spider-tr072.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wa022.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wa041.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wa051.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wa063.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wb011.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wb034.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wb044.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wc024.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wc042.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wd034.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wd041.proxy.aol.com 
spider-we053.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wg042.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wg044.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wg053.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wi011.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wi021.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wi022.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wj024.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wj043.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wj052.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wj062.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wk011.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wk012.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wk014.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wk053.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wk061.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wk062.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wl032.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wl042.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wl051.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wm023.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wm031.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wm032.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wm034.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wn014.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wn021.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wn031.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wn062.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wo014.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wo021.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wo053.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wo061.proxy.aol.com 
spider-wo063.proxy.aol.com 
ww-pa01.proxy.aol.com 
ww-pa02.proxy.aol.com 
ww-pa03.proxy.aol.com 
ww-ta01.proxy.aol.com 
ww-ta02.proxy.aol.com 
ww-ta03.proxy.aol.com 
ww-ta04.proxy.aol.com 
ww-ta05.proxy.aol.com 

The first set actually are the bulk of aol's 3LDs -- they 
seem to be domain names generated for dialup users that are dynamically 
allocated as people dial in.  Notice that they just are algorithmic 
mappings of the IP address.  Notice too, from the figures below, 
that the figures are by hosts, not number of domains, and that by far 
the largest portion of the "hosts" are on on aols "ipt.aol.com".  
Note further that "hosts" is an incorrect term -- "IP address" is 
the correct term -- they have absolutely no way of detecting 
interfaces with multiple IP addresses...

The same is true for uunet and most of the other large ISPs -- they 
do not, contrary to the myth you are perpetrating, serve as public 
registries of large numbers of domain names -- they are simply 
naming IP addresses on their own networks.

This example also illustrates why there is some necessity for 
technical clue in DNS policy, and also that many of the most vocal 
participants simply don't have that clue.


> FYI:
> 
> 
> At 2/24/99, 08:07 PM, Rahmat M. Samik-Ibrahim wrote:
> >
> >=== ZCZC F.31 == (Forwarded from Mark Lottor) ====================
> >
> >Internet Domain Survey      Network Wizards       January 1999
> >
> >                     <http://www.nw.com>
> >
> >The Domain Survey attempts to discover every host on the Internet 
> >by doinga complete search of the Domain Name System.  The latest 
> >survey was done during late January 1999.  The complete results 
> >can be found on our web site.  Here is a summary of the more 
> >interesting things:
> >                                                  -- Mark Lottor
> >
> >
> >Hosts found (number of PTR records):              43,230,000
> >
> >Hosts pingable:                                    8,426,000
> > [estimated by pinging 1% of total hosts found]
> >
> >Top 10 TLDs (number of hosts):
> > com   12140747         mil    1510440
> > net    8856687         uk     1423804
> > edu    5022815         de     1316893
> > jp     1687534         ca     1119172
> > us     1562391         au      792351
> >
> >Top 10 second-level domains (number of hosts):
> >
> > 1667245 aol.com                 585233 co.uk
> > 1238252 uu.net                  505645 ne.jp
> >  848820 ans.net                 485316 bbn.com
> >  708159 ac.uk                   424038 or.jp
> >  637202 af.mil                  403169 att.net
> >
> >Top 10 third-level domains (number of hosts):
> >
> > 1657627 ipt.aol.com             296541 pub-ip.psi.net
> > 1213999 da.uu.net               280735 demon.co.uk
> >  817846 dialup.ans.net          226000 k12.ca.us
> >  465891 saturn.bbn.com          181681 us.ibm.net
> >  400796 dial-access.att.net     145918 k12.mn.us
> >
> >Top 10 hostnames:
> >
> >  872992 www                      17225 ns
> >  141835 host                     14759 ftp
> >   84130 mail                     13680 gw
> >   62756 dummy                    10102 server
> >   22849 router                    9884 user
> 
> 
> Respectfully,
> 
> Jay Fenello
> President, Iperdome, Inc.  
> 404-943-0524  http://www.iperdome.com

-- 
Kent Crispin                               "Do good, and you'll be
[EMAIL PROTECTED]                           lonesome." -- Mark Twain

Reply via email to