Michael,

The principle is well taken, but is not complete. I'm not familiar with the
Wolfe note as a name, but we are all aware that there are certain
frequencies that will resonate better in a soundbox/soundboard combination -
and that can vary with the design. I give you the harp, with no "rose" hole
in the sound board. There is an access hole in the back to get to the
strings to replace them - except in the Paraguayan harp, with a thin "shell
shaped" back like the lute and an access hole at the base. I have no idea
what a harp would sound like with a fully enclosed sound box - no one will
make one as the original strings would have to last forever. But one could
make that theoretical harp with a resonating chamber that would favor
certain notes. But more likely the main factor would yet be the sympathetic
resonance of the strings within the overtone series of the plucked string.

It is my opinion that the specifics of the sound hole are less important
than the overall range of resonation of the soundboard. And that involves
the bracing, the sound hole, the backing for the rosette, and whatever else
is involved. I'm sure one could make a "lute/guitar" that would project well
without a soundhole, but not sure how to do it. It would be a matter of
material.

Best, Jon


Reply via email to