>> Anyway, Frescobaldi PETITIONED Vatican for an ET organ. And that's >> Standard >> Scholarship. > > And then, if we forget for a while your claims about Monteverdi using ET, > could you repeat the words Frescobaldi used when he "petitioned" something > for the Vatican organ? And it would really be interesting to be able to > read the "Standard Scholarship" statement on this matter! And who is the > scholar, who claims GF using ET? I do know that for example Stravinsky > believed they longed for - and even used - ET already in the 16th > century, but I really do not consider IS having been a scholar... > > Arto > > PS Dear Roman, perhaps early and middle baroque are not in the center > of your knowledge and interest... ;-) No, they are not, I generally rely on friends in this. But the partisan adherence to meantone is equally unscolarly. RT
To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html
