Yes--the wimmer is the one I use. When Wimmer says autograph I believe he means it in the sense of Holograph.
A nice example of holograph vs autograph; Magdalena is considered autograph for the cello suites because it is not in the composer's handwriting, unless anna arranged (or had a hand in composing) them, in which case it is sticky :) The other version of the C minor, which is purported to be the only one in Sebastian's handwriting, would then, if true, be holograph. The Grove's Stanley Boorman elucidates this distinction most cogently: "A document written in the hand of the author or composer. This distinguishes it from the more commonly used word, <http://0-www.grovemusic.com.www.berkeley-public.org/shared/components/article/article_sourceid_resolver.html?source_section_id=S01567>Autograph, for the latter, strictly, means merely that the document is written by someone who can be named. Thus, an accounting of the manuscripts written by C.P.E. Bach would include not only his holographs, copies of his own compositions, but also his autograph copies of the works of his father, J.S. Bach. Similarly, the father's holographs of his own works need to be distinguished from his autograph copies of music by such composers as Caldara or Lotti, or Grigny. " If T'Pring had copied Spock's love song it would be autograph, had she composed it it would be holograph, and so on. And performed on the holodeck. dt At 02:02 PM 1/26/2008, you wrote: >There is a facsimile at: > >http://www.wimmercello.com/bachs5ms.html > >On 26.01.2008, at 22:47, David Tayler wrote: > >>The Bach Suite editions on Icking have a lot of mistakes in them. >>You can find the facsimile on the internet, if I have time I'll do >>that tonight. >>dt >> >>At 01:44 PM 1/26/2008, you wrote: >>>The music can be found in Werner Icking's archive which is normally >>>quite reliable and a great source. >>> >>>http://icking-music-archive.org/scores/bach/cello_suites/vc100712.pdf >>> >>>g >>> >>>On 26.01.2008, at 22:33, Roman Turovsky wrote: >>> >>>>Could anyone check whether the cello version of BWV 995 has >>>>picardy thirds the lute version hasn't ? >>>>I don't have the material handy. >>>>RT >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>>To get on or off this list see list information at >>>>http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html >> > --
