> -----Original Message-----
> 
> The operating system A files compatible with operating system B
> seems to be more of a job for a translator, not a disk emulator.

Here's the thing - it's both.  If it were purely a disk emulator, it'd put the 
files into a 200k disk image file on the PC end of things and we'd get to treat 
it like a black box, or maybe some kind soul would write another utility to 
copy and translate text files in and out of the disk image files.  LaddieAlpha 
is a translator in the sense that it's taking files and folders from whatever 
filesystem the host OS uses and making them visible to the Model T DOS in a 
form it will understand.  Among other things, this means translating filenames 
to uppercase, truncating filenames to 6.2 characters in length, possibly more 
filename mangling if said truncation results in namespace collision, etc.

I like data integrity as much as the next guy, but having said that, there's a 
place for 'low level' software that preserves the data integrity 100%, and then 
there's a place for software which does whatever it can to make life easier for 
the user, including making assumptions that .DO files should contain text and 
should not contain an extraneous EOF if its presence in a text document on a 
Model T leads more or less immediately to filesystem corruption.

Maybe there should be an option to enable transfer of files without 
modification, and maybe there shouldn't.  John's making software to help users 
transfer files, so these choices are really up to him.







        jim

Reply via email to