Roaming Charges: In ICE Cold Blood - CounterPunch.org
Roaming Charges: In ICE Cold Blood
Many of the people who have spent the last five years denouncing the killing of 
Ashli Babbitt for raiding the Capitol in an attempt to overturn an election are 
celebrating the murder of Renee Nichole Good, a terrified mother killed by 
masked men from unmarked cars who chased her down a neighborhood street and 
shot her in the face.
At 9:30 on Wednesday morning, Renee Good was sitting in her Honda Pilot, with 
her life partner and dog, on Portland Avenue in the Central neighborhood of 
Minneapolis, when two unmarked cars approached her. Good waved her hand, 
signaling for the unmarked cars to go around her. Instead, they stopped.  
Masked men got out. Good told them: “I’m pulling out.”
As two of the men advanced near her maroon Pilot, one of them told her to 
“Move, move, move,” while the other shouted, “Get out of the fucking car.” 
These contradictory instructions are a frequent tactic, since, however you 
respond, you violate one of the orders, and offer an excuse for escalation.
One of the masked men tried to open the passenger door and reach through the 
window toward Good. Meanwhile, the other agent grabbed the side door. Good put 
her car in reverse, backed up a little, then pulled forward slowly, turning 
away from the masked ICE agent who was slightly in front of her. He moves out 
of the way, almost casually. As the officer who would kill her seconds later 
stood outside the window of her Honda, Good said, “That’s fine dude, I’m not 
mad at you. Then the officer dropped his cellphone, grabbed his gun, fired 
three shots into Good’s car, hitting her in the face, and grunted, “Fuckin’ 
bitch.”
As she slumped forward, her foot reflexively pressed down on the accelerator 
and the car lurched forward, hitting a parked car and a light pole a few yards 
down the street, where it came to a rest. Her partner was heard screaming, 
“They’ve killed my wife! “They killed my wife. I don’t know what to do. They 
shot her in the head.”
A bystander who witnessed the shooting rushed forward to help, but was stopped 
by an ICE agent. The man said he was a doctor and could render medical aid to 
the woman who was shot. The ICE agent responded brusquely: “I don’t care,” and 
ordered him to stay back. Fifteen minutes passed until an ambulance pulled onto 
Portland Avenue. But it was blocked from coming to Good’s aid by ICE vehicles. 
Finally, two paramedics trekked through the snow to the scene of the shooting, 
where they tried to treat Good’s fatal wounds. She was later pronounced dead at 
Hennepin Hospital.
Before her blood was even dry, the President and his henchmen had smeared this 
bright young woman, this mother and poet, as a domestic terrorist, as an 
attempted assassin, as a leftist thug. They smeared her before knowing anything 
about her, what she’d done that day, how she lived her life, who she loved and 
cared for, what her friends and neighbors and colleagues thought of her. To 
Trump and his minions, she was an obstacle, someone standing in the way and, 
therefore, someone who deserved whatever she got, even if it was a bullet in 
the face.
Now the FBI is blocking Minnesota law enforcement officials from analyzing 
evidence from the shooting. You wonder why they bother. What is there to hide? 
The murder of Renee Good happened in plain sight. We’ve all seen it from 
various angles. There was no one in front of Good’s car when she pulled out. No 
one was run over. The shots were fired from the side, not the front of her 
Honda. The ICE agent shot her and he walked away. He didn’t limp. He didn’t 
flinch in pain. He simply walked away. He didn’t seek treatment from the 
paramedics on the scene. Or show any wounds to his fellow agents. He just 
walked away.  He walked around the scene for three minutes. Then he got in a 
car and left. (The Intercept identified the alleged shooter as Jonathan Ross, 
an ICE agent based in St. Paul.) Renee Good was denied medical care and left to 
bleed out in her car. There’s nothing left to cover up.
And perhaps that’s how ICE and the Trump administration want it. 

Renee Nicole Good. Photo: Old Dominion University English Department/Facebook.
ICE’s rules of engagement are to intimidate, to terrify. And not just its 
targets, but entire neighborhoods, communities and cities. They brutalize the 
innocent not by accident but by tactic. They offer the security of fear. They 
want you so afraid of them that you’ll snitch your neighbor out, turn in the 
women who clean your toilets and take care of your kids, denounce the men who 
mow your lawn, rake your leaves and clean your gutters. They want you to stay 
inside with your doors locked when you hear a familiar voice scream, as masked 
men raid your block. 
Like the cascading violence of the raids themselves, the smearing of the victim 
is strategic. It’s meant to frighten and paralyze those who might otherwise 
object. Stand in the way and you will be blamed for whatever happens to you. 
You will be slimed and slandered beyond all recognition. If you survive, your 
life will be made hellish, your reputation splattered with lies and calumnies 
by your own government. 
ICE has killed before and will kill again.
In the last year, ICE agents have fired shots at least 15 times, killing four 
people. They shot at people trying to warn them of children in the area of 
their raids and they shot people running away from them. They shot people in a 
very similar way that they shot Renee Good: while they were in their cars, 
driving away and then blamed them for trying to run over ICE officers. On 
September 3, an ICE agent shot and killed Silverio Villegas-Gonzalez, a Mexican 
national, after dropping his daughter off at pre-school. ICE originally said 
that Villegas-Gonzalez was shot after he tried to run over an ICE agent, who 
DHS claimed had been severely wounded. Then, a video of the incident recorded 
the voice of the officer grazed by Villegas-Gonzalez’s car saying his injury 
was “nothing major.” Another video showed that Villegas-Gonzalez was driving 
away from the ICE officers, not toward them. DHS tried to smear 
Villegas-Gonzalez as a dangerous criminal with a “history of reckless driving.” 
But a new report by NBC News Chicago shows that he had never been convicted or 
even charged with a crime.
On October 4, an immigration agent shot Marimar Martinez five times while the 
30-year-old teaching assistant and US citizen was driving around the Brighton 
Park neighborhood of Chicago, warning residents of an impending ICE raid. The 
Border Patrol officer who shot Martinez pulled up beyond her car and shouted, 
“Do something, bitch!,” as he aimed his assault rifle at her. He later bragged 
about the shooting in a text message to fellow agents: “I fired 5 rounds and 
she had 7 holes. Put that in your book boys.” The agents falsely claimed that 
Martinez had tried to ram them with her car and arrested the seriously wounded 
woman. The charges against her were later dismissed.
A day after the Minneapolis shootings, Border Patrol agents in Portland shot 
two people, a man and a woman, during a traffic stop in the parking of a 
medical center complex. Once again they claimed they had tried to use the 
vehicle as a weapon, although both of them couldn’t have been driving at the 
same time. DHS also claimed both were members of the Tren de Aragua gang, 
though they offered no evidence to buttress the charge. The couple, who are 
reportedly married, escaped on foot and were later taken by Portland to a 
hospital. The man was shot twice and the woman suffered a gunshot wound to the 
chest. Portland’s Mayor, Keith Wilson, called for ICE and Border Patrol to 
leave the city, saying “Portland isn’t a training ground for militarized 
agents.”
So in the course of two days, Trump’s immigration shock troops shot a mother of 
three and a married couple.
These kinds of raids, while shocking to most Americans, are familiar to many 
immigrants from Honduras, Guatemala and El Salvador, countries still haunted by 
the death squads funded, armed and trained by the CIA. Horrors that they fled 
and have now reappeared like ghosts from the past here on the streets of 
Chicago and Minneapolis and Los Angeles. They know all too well that collateral 
damage is a feature of all paramilitaries. 
With the murder of Renee Good, ICE has now advanced from scaring the hell out 
of American citizens to killing them.
Jeffrey St Clair


  


-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group.
View/Reply Online (#40112): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/40112
Mute This Topic: https://groups.io/mt/117199911/21656
-=-=-
POSTING RULES & NOTES
#1 YOU MUST clip all extraneous text when replying to a message.
#2 This mail-list, like most, is publicly & permanently archived.
#3 Subscribe and post under an alias if #2 is a concern.
#4 Do not exceed five posts a day.
-=-=-
Group Owner: [email protected]
Unsubscribe: https://groups.io/g/marxmail/leave/13617172/21656/1316126222/xyzzy 
[[email protected]]
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-


Reply via email to